KORLEY vs. STATE CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION [1982-83] GLR 576
24 July 1979 · CECILIA KORANTENG-ADDOW J · ≈ 15 min read
[1979] SLR (HC) 81Other citation styles and permanent link
SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.
CASES REFERRED TO
(1) Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co., Ltd. v. English [1938] AC 57; [1937] 3 All E.R. 628; 106 L.J.P.C.
117; 157 L.T. 406; 53 T.L.R. 994, H.L.
(2) General Cleaning Contractors Ltd. v. Christmas [1953] A.C. 180; [1952] 2 All E.R. 1110; 97 S.J. 7;
51 L.G.R. 109, H.L.
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS
ACTION by the plaintiff for damages for injuries sustained in the course of his employment with the defendants. The facts are sufficiently set out in the judgment.
COUNSEL
J. Alarah for the plaintiff.
S. A. X. Tsegah for the defendants.
JUDGMENT OF KORANTENG-ADDOW J.
At all material times, the plaintiff was a carpenter employed by the defendants. His employment commenced in 1958 and he retired as a headman carpenter in 1973. On 21 November 1973, he was injured while he was engaged in dismantling a prefabricated structure. In this action, he claims general damages against the State Construction Corporation for their negligence.
The circumstances leading to the plaintiff’s injuries are these: On the date in question, he was instructed to go to the job site No. 515 in the neighbourhood of the Military Hospital to dismantle a prefabricated structure which had been erected and used for offices. The plaintiff was detailed to dismantle the structure with another carpenter, called Sosu and a labourer. They set to work in this order; first they took off the roof; next they dismantled one side of the walls, then started on the second wall. The whole structure was partitioned with a ceiling card into two rooms. The second panel was ripped up to the partition. Before they started pulling down the panels, they supported them with two boards. At one time all the workers were in one room.
After they had brought the second wall down, Sosu went to the other room but the plaintiff remained in the first room. As the roof had been ripped off, they were within sight of each other. The labourer left the structure for a place of convenience. At that stage, the plaintiff said he saw a nail dangerously sticking out on the floor of the room where he was, so he bent down to remove it. He said he used pincers. While he was trying to pull out the nail, he heard Sosu give a shout of warning and then he saw the third wall coming down. The wall crumbled down on him. He said he tried to ward off the danger by stretching out both arms towards the falling wooden panel but the weight sent him down with the wall. He fell unconscious but regained it when the weight was lifted from him. Then he and Sosu examined the joints of
[p.579] of [1982-83] GLR 576 the fallen wooden panel and the remaining panel adjacent to it and they found that an ordinary small nail had been used to fasten the two joints. With regards to his injuries it was pleaded on his behalf that he had fracture of the pelvis, concussion, crush injuries of both legs, both shoulders and neck and both arms, damage to the tissues of both nostrils; and sexual weakness. His evidence on his injuries were: “I felt pains at the head, neck and waist, my feet could not properly support my weight.” He also complained of chest pains. According to him, even though after the plank had been lifted from him he regained consciousness, he could not speak, so his workmate, Sosu, assisted to find a taxi to convey him to the Labadi polyclinic where he saw Dr. Dewhurst. He could not talk to the doctor, so he merely talked by signs, by pointing to the affected parts of his body and his workmate narrated the story of his injuries to the doctor. He was detained for the day for treatment and discharged home later the same day. He continued to go for further treatment regularly for about five months and then retired from work on health grounds.
As a result of this accident he claims that he has become an invalid and has been compelled to retire prematurely from his job and furthermore that he has become sexually impotent.
The action has been seriously contested by the defendants. They have contended that the incident complained about had been caused by the negligence of the plaintiff himself, and that the defendants had taken all reasonable care for the safety of their workmen, including the plaintiff.
A carpenter foreman of the State Construction Corporation testified on behalf of the defendants. His evidence was that he supervised the erection of the structure which collapsed onto the plaintiff, and that the boards at the corners were 2” x 4” so they used 6 inches nails to fasten the corner joints. He said the dimension of one side of the walls was 14 feet x 22 inches and normally it required three to four people to dismantle one structure of that type. On the method of dismantling he said, all the walls were numbered in numerical order and that the starting point for dismantling is the wall with the lowest number. He said before the actual dismantling commences, all the four corners of the structure must be braced, otherwise there will be imbalance, and the unsupported side may collapse. These, according to him are elementary rules in carpentry.
In his written address submitted to the court, Mr. Alarah argued that the defendants failed to provide competent staff, adequate material and proper system of work and effective supervision. Mr. Tsegah, counsel for the defendants, contended that no negligence was established against the defendants but as the plaintiff was injured in the course of his employment he is entitled to be compensated under the Workmen Compensation Act, 1963 (Act 174).
[p.580] of [1982-83] GLR 576
The vital issue that has to be decided is whether the plaintiff sustained his injuries as a result of the defendants’ negligence or his own negligence. An employer owes a duty to his workman to see that reasonable care is taken for the workman’s safety. In spite of the scheme of compensation instituted under Act 174, higher damages may be claimed for breach of the common law duty. The locus classicus on the subject is Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co., Ltd. v. English [1938] A.C. 57, H.L. in which Lord Wright described the obligation of the master towards his employee at p. 78 as being threefold namely: “the provision of a competent staff of men, adequate material, and a proper system and effective supervision.” In this case counsel maintains that the defendants were in breach of their duty under all the three heads. It is necessary therefore to examine the evidence, determine what case has been made against the defendants, and decide whether or not that amounts to negligence.
In the statement of claim, the particulars of negligence alleged against the defendants were stated in paragraph 4:
“(a) failing to ensure that the structure was supported properly or at all;
(b) failing to ensure that the structure was erected and maintained using the proper size bolts and nuts where required;
(c) failing to ensure that the number of men detailed to dismantle the structure was adequate to ensure the safety of the workers;
(d) causing or permitting their servants or agents to attempt to dismantle the structure without ensuring that sufficient supports were placed to prevent an accident.”
No particulars were given of paragraph 4(a) but the evidence shows that if the structure had been supported with planks of wood or any long object strong and firm to hold the walls in place, it would not have collapsed. Paragraph 4(d) is of the same substance as paragraph 4(a) expressed in different words. These complaints may be placed under the obligation to provide effective supervision. The complaint particularised under paragraph 4(b) and 4(c) may be described as failure to provide adequate material and to devise a safe system of work. From the evidence, I find that the wall collapsed because it was not supported after the first and second walls had been brought down. I do not think it would have made much difference whether or not the joints were held together by 6 inches nails or the small nails described by the plaintiff. The plaintiff could not have seen what type of nails were used. As a carpenter if he had examined the joints and seen the type of nails used, he would have been able to say what size of nails
[p.581] of [1982-83] GLR 576 they were he would not have called them “small small nails.” From his own showing, the plaintiff could not have examined the joints as he claimed. If he passed out and recovered consciousness but he could not speak nor help himself, then one wonders with what strength or voice he communicated with his workmate, examined the joints and found the “small small nails.”
When the fallacy in his evidence was laid bare to him during cross-examination, the plaintiff said that he talked to his workmate Sosu by signs. I do not think the plaintiff was in a condition to undertake that assignment, he could not have seen what nails were used. The evidence of the carpenter foreman, Yawdza, is more reasonable and probable. He did not see the structure after the accident, but he said he supervised the erection of it and he saw to it that 6 inches nails were used for the joints. He said such structures were built for temporary use so they were dismantled when their usefulness ceased.
He emphasised that bolts and nuts were not used for temporary structures. This is a more reasonable account of the erection than the plaintiff’s evidence. It is immaterial that he did not see the dismantled structure, because the nails could not have disappeared or changed their sizes by the time of the accident. But as I said earlier, I do not think the structure collapsed because of inadequate fastening of the joints but due to lack of proper support.
I also discern from the evidence that when the defendants asked the plaintiff and the two others to dismantle the structure they did not give any effective supervision. They merely told them to dismantle the structure and left them to use their own initiative. The defendants’ carpenter foreman said that there is a system used to dismantle such structures and this was of common knowledge to carpenters of the corporation. The work which the plaintiff had to do was not new to him. It may be inferred from his evidence that he was not a novice, he was an experienced carpenter, he said it was by virtue of his being an expert in the field that he was assigned the job. It was also alleged that he knew that if he did not support the structure on all sides before dismantling it, it would collapse on him. This is evidence of the fact that the defendants knew of the perils involved in the job. They knew that if the walls were not braced the structure would collapse on the people engaged in the dismantling exercise. Yet the defendants took no steps to protect the workmen engaged in the exercise. There is no evidence that sufficient number of boards were provided to brace all the four corners of that structure. If they were provided, there is no evidence that anybody supervised the workmen nor made sure they used them.
The defendants were under a duty to see that a safe system of work and adequate materials and supervision were provided. Mr. Mensah took them from Asylum Down to the work site and left them. One Mr. Ganning was the foreman in charge of the work but he did
[p.582] of [1982-83] GLR 576 not go to the site until he was called there after the accident. Admittedly, the plaintiff is a headman and he said he had dismantled similar structures previously; but his experience in the work did not discharge the defendants of their obligation to supervise him and see that the method he used was the method adopted and recommended by them. I think that in that regard, they failed in their common law duty. Since the defendants knew that if the corners were not supported, an accident like the one under inquiry would occur, they had a duty to see that the materials were provided for support, and to see that they were used. No safeguards whatever were provided. It is well known to employers that employees are habitually careless about the risks which their work may involve. As it was said by Lord Oaksey in General Cleaning Contractors Ltd. v. Christmas [1953] A.C. 180 at pp. 189-190, H.L.:
“It is, in my opinion, for that very reason that the common law demands that employers should take reasonable care to lay down a reasonably safe system of work. Employers are not exempted from this duty by the fact that their men are experienced and might, if they were in the position of an employer, be able to lay down a reasonably safe system of work themselves. Workmen are not in the position of employers. Their duties are not performed in the calm atmosphere of a board room with the advice of experts. They have to make their decisions on narrow window sills and other places of danger and in circumstances in which the dangers are obscured by repetition.”
In that case, the respondent was an experienced window cleaner who had been for 20 years in the employ of the appellant-company. The appellant sent the respondent to clean the library windows of a club. According to the system adopted, the window cleaner stood on the window sill outside to clean the panes which could not be reached from the inside. There had been complaints that some windows at the club were defective, for occasionally, the sash moved at the slightest touch. Following the method used by the employers the respondent cleaned the part of the window which could be reached from inside and then got to the sill outside which was 6 1/4 inches wide and 27 ft. above the basement. It was necessary to keep the bottom sash open so that the respondent could grip at the bottom edge of the top sash and to support himself. While the respondent was still standing outside cleaning, the window shut so that it could not be opened from outside; the woodwork at the top of the bottom sash came down upon his fingers and he lost his balance and fell. In an action by the employee for damages, his employers contended he was negligent for failing to equip himself with a safety belt, and in taking no step to wedge or
[p.583] of [1982-83] GLR 576 secure the window. The employers were held liable, for failing in their obligation to devise a reasonably safe system of work for an obvious danger.
That case is not very different from the one under consideration. From the evidence of the foreman, the defendants were aware of the perils or dangers involved in this dismantling exercise, yet they neither gave instructions to ensure that supports were used nor provided these supports. They left it to the initiatives of the workmen to take precautions against a common danger. The risk could have been eliminated or reduced by instructions that the structure should be supported on all four corners before the dismantling work began. But they did nothing of the sort. They relied on the experience of the workmen. The defendants failed to discharge their duty of care towards the plaintiff.
There is one small aspect of the case I would like to comment on briefly. The plaintiff in his particularisation of negligence, averred that too few men were detailed to do the job. In giving evidence he said six to eight people should have dismantled the structure. The cause of this accident is clear; after two sides of the structure had been removed, the third wall was imbalanced, no support was used to brace it, so it collapsed. At the time, the people were not actually engaged in the dismantling exercise.
There was a pause; the labourer had left for a place of convenience, Sosu was in another section of the room; and while waiting the plaintiff saw a nail which he decided to remove. I do not know how this accident could have been averted if there were more people around to do the work. Even though the plaintiff denied it under cross-examination, I think the commotion he caused in removing the nail contributed to send the wall on him. But if the wall had been wedged, the shaking of the walls by the commotion could not have disturbed its balance.
I find that it was the duty of the defendants to instruct their workmen, even though skilled at their jobs, on what they should do, how they should do it, and supply any implements that may be required. They have failed in this duty and they must be held liable in negligence.
Damages
The injuries pleaded are not supported in evidence. The plaintiff did not suffer any external injury. His injuries consist of aches and pains for which he was treated and discharged on the same day. These aches persisted so the plaintiff continued to go for treatment but he did not appear to benefit much from his treatment. After receiving treatment for five months without any apparent change in his improvement, he was admitted into the Ridge Hospital for observation.
[p.584] of [1982-83] GLR 576
In his report, Dr. Dewhurst said that the plaintiff was admitted in 1976 for asthma. I do not think this is related to the accident in any way.
The prognosis is that the plaintiff is an invalid and sexually impotent. X-rays taken of the plaintiff’s affected parts did not reveal any malady or injury. Yet the plaintiff still has these aches, which the doctor described as crippling. I have seen the plaintiff a few times, he walks with the aid of a walking stick and with great difficulty. Even though the doctor could not diagnose anything, it appears that the accident affected him much more than can be explained. The medical report described him as “a very sick man,” without any objective report on his condition. His condition is so bad that he has been retired from work on the advice of the medical officer. His disability is assessed at 50 per cent.
He did not give his age, but he appears to me to be about 50. It is also not in the evidence on what terms he was retired or what benefit he received. But his salary at the time was ¢1.50 per diem. He did not say how much salary or losses in terms of money he has lost or incurred. However, these are the heads of damage which may be considered in computing the plaintiff’s case. He has suffered pain and loss of amenities. His pain has persisted from the time of the accident, and it is still continuing, he has lost amenities of life. In his present condition, the plaintiff cannot do the things he enjoyed doing before the accident. He cannot stand on his feet, and he walks with a lot of strain.
The plaintiff undoubtedly retired before reaching the retiring age, so he must have lost some earnings. He complains of impotence. The doctor said he guessed this condition may be due to the accident. He did not give any basis for his guesswork. But looking closely at the nature of injuries sustained, aches at pelvis, neck and head, it is not easy to hold that he has suffered this incapacity as a result of the accident. Yet there appears to be much more wrong with him than the medical evidence can explain. He is obviously not a strong man, and this condition has come about as a result of this accident. His premature retirement will mean a loss of some money to him. I am not in a position to determine the extent of the loss because the terms of his retirement are not stated. Definitely if he remained at work until the compulsory retiring age of 55, his benefits would definitely have been more than whatever was paid to him.
Therefore considering his pain and suffering, loss of amenities, loss of retiring benefits, I would assess his damages at ¢5,500 with C800 as costs.
DECISION
Judgment for the plaintiff.
M. C. N.-N.
