SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1979] SLR (HC) 61High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1980

REPUBLIC vs. CHIEF FIRE OFFICER EX PARTE AZAGBA [1980] GLR 213

8 March 1979 · MENSA BOISON J · ≈ 6 min read

Cite as[1979] SLR (HC) 61
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAREPUBLIC v CHIEF FIRE OFFICER ex parte AZAGBA [1980] GLR 213 [1979] SLR (HC) 61
APAREPUBLIC v CHIEF FIRE OFFICER ex parte AZAGBA [1980] GLR 213, [1979] SLR (HC) 61 (Ghana).
BluebookREPUBLIC v CHIEF FIRE OFFICER ex parte AZAGBA [1980] GLR 213, [1979] SLR (HC) 61 (Ghana High Ct. 1979).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASE REFERRED TO

Board of Education v. Rice [1911] A.C. 179; 80 L.J.K.B. 796; 104 L.T. 689; 75 JP. 393; 27 TLR 378; 55 S.J. 440; 9 L.G.R. 652, H.L.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPLICATION for an order of mandamus to issue compelling the Chief Fire Officer to furnish the applicant with copies of the record of proceedings of a disciplinary tribunal which adjudged the applicant guilty of misconduct, resulting in his dismissal from the National Fire Service. The facts are sufficiently set out in the ruling.

COUNSEL

Tham for the applicant.

Miss Amassah, Senior State Attorney, for the respondents.

JUDGMENT OF MENSA BOISON J.

The applicant asks for an order of mandamus to issue to compel the Chief Fire Officer to furnish the applicant with copies of the record of proceedings of a disciplinary tribunal which adjudged the applicant guilty of misconduct, resulting in his dismissal from the National Fire Service (hereafter referred to as the service).

The affidavit in support states that the applicant was an assistant divisional fire officer in the service. Sometime in October 1978 he appeared before a disciplinary tribunal, constituted under the Fire Services Regulations, 1965 (LI 561), to answer charges of misconduct under regulations 19 of the regulations. Upon the decision of the Chief Fire Officer as the disciplinary authority to dismiss him, the appealing against the decision of the disciplinary authority. The Chief Fire Officer denied the request on the ground that the regulations did not oblige him to do so, except to notify the decision of the tribunal to the applicant.

As already mentioned, the proceedings of the disciplinary tribunal are governed by the Fire Services Regulations, 1965. Regulations 20 and 22 (3) provide that:

“20. A member of the Service charged with an offence under regulation 19 shall be liable to appear before a Disciplinary Tribunal consisting of one or more officers not below the rank of Assistant Divisional Officer appointed by the Chief Fire Officer.”

“22. (3) The Disciplinary Tribunal shall, after a hearing record its findings and as soon as practicable cause its decision to be notified in writing to the person charged.”

Provision is also made under regulation 24 for an appeal from the decision of the said tribunal to the minister whose decision shall be final. It is in exercise of this right, given by regulation 24, that the applicant demanded but was refused copies of the aforesaid proceedings.

On the submission of learned counsel for the respondent, the first respondent by virtue of regulation 22 (3) of L.I. 461 is relieved from any obligation of supplying the applicant with a copy of the

[p.216] of [1980] GLR 213 proceedings when demanded. In counsel’s view the charge sheet, of which the applicant had a copy, and the decision as notified under regulation 22 (3) were adequate for all purposes of an appeal to the minister, which takes the form of a petition.

It was her further submission that the regulations having effectually provided for what is necessary for the process of appeal, there was no room left to supplement the provisions of L.I. 461 with any provisions of the Civil Service (Interim) Regulations, 1960 (L.I. 47).

The provisions of L.I. 47 are brought into play by incorporation under regulation 27 of L.I. 461 which provides, “Except where otherwise in these Regulations provided the provisions of the Civil Service (Interim) Regulations, 1960 (L.I. 47) shall apply to the Service as they apply to the Civil Service.”

The effect to my mind is that the regulations in L.I. 461 are intended to be supplemented by the provisions of L.I. 47, where a particular subject-matter is not provided for under the regulations.

It is the contention of Mr. Tham that the regulations are silent as to the subject-matter of the provisions of regulations 60 (5) of accused civil servant with copies of the record of proceedings. Consequently, it is urged that regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47 is deemed to be incorporated in L.I. 461 by force of regulation 27 of L.I. 461. Regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47 reads:

“(5) A civil servant who wishes to appeal against a decision taken by a disciplinary authority following formal proceedings may be given a record of the reports (including, where reasonable, copies of documents tendered in evidence or the relevant parts thereof) on payment…”

I am unable to accede to the submission of the senior state attorney that the subject-matter of regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47 is covered by regulation 22 (3) of L.I. 461. I think the equivalent provision to regulation 22 (3) of L.I. 461 in L.I. 47 is rather regulation 64 (14) which enjoins the disciplinary authority on conclusion of the proceedings to inform the accused civil servant of the report of the enquiry officer in these terms, “The accused civil servant shall be informed in writing as to whether the charge or charges are established and what penalty, if any, has been imposed.”

Now the fact of the matter seems to me to rest on two rules of natural justice: firstly, it is a requirement of the exercise of a jurisdiction that the tribunal shall take into consideration the relevant facts. And certiorari will lie where the tribunal instead wrongly considered

[p.217] of [1980] GLR 213 irrelevant or extraneous matters: see Board of Education v. Rice [1911] A.C. 179, H.L. The minister as the appellate tribunal under regulation 22 (3) of L.I. 461 must of necessity instruct his mind of the record of proceedings and of the evidence. It is only then that he will avail himself of the relevant facts to come to a just decision on the appeal.

Secondly, in formulating his petition of appeal, the applicant can best do this if he were in possession of a copy of the proceedings and the record of evidence, the better to draw the minister’s attention to the record of evidence, the better to draw the minister’s attention to the strength of his own defence or the weakness of the evidence of his prosecutor. I am unable to accept the submission that the charge sheet and the material under regulation 22 (3) of the regulations will be sufficient for that purpose.

The rules of natural justice demand a full and fair hearing of the applicant as the appellant. I am satisfied that to deny the applicant of copies of the proceedings is not only a breach of the audi alteram partem rule, but is contrary to the mandate of regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47. Although regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47 directs that “A civil servant who wishes to appeal … may be given a record of the report …,” I am of the opinion that where an appellant cannot effectively formulate his petition without copies of the proceedings then the permissive “may” will be properly construed as mandatory.

In this case, I do not doubt the sincerity of counsel that the copy of proceedings is needed for effective presentation of the petition. The respondent’s only ground of refusal is that they are limited to supply only the material under regulation 22 (3) of L.I. 461. That I am satisfied was an erroneous view of the law; since it obviously ignores of the regulation, I am satisfied that the applicant is entitled to the fees, as regulated by regulation 60 (5) of L.I. 47. Reciprocally, the first respondent is by that enactment under a duty to comply with the demand, and I hereby order mandamus to issue directed to the respondents to comply with the demand.

Costs of ¢150 to the applicant.

DECISION

Application granted with costs.

D. R. K. S.

Scroll to Top