SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1982] SLR (HC) 5High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL I)

BENNEH vs. NEW TIMES CORPORATION AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 302

23 November 1982 · AMPIAH J · ≈ 13 min read

Cite as[1982] SLR (HC) 5
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLABENNEH v NEW TIMES CORPORATION AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 302 [1982] SLR (HC) 5
APABENNEH v NEW TIMES CORPORATION AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 302, [1982] SLR (HC) 5 (Ghana).
BluebookBENNEH v NEW TIMES CORPORATION AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 302, [1982] SLR (HC) 5 (Ghana High Ct. 1982).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

ACTION for damages for libel by a public officer in respect of two publications in a newspaper. The facts are fully set out in the judgement.

[p.305] of [1982-83] GLR 302

COUNSEL

Kofi Gyambrah for the plaintiff.

Obeng-Manu for the defendants.

JUDGMENT OF AMPIAH J.

By his writ of summons, the plaintiff claims from the defendants jointly and severally ¢50,000 damages for defamation. The plaintiff, until the termination of his appointment on or about 1 November 1979, was the regional manager of the Food Distribution Corporation at Sunyani in the Brong-Ahafo Region of Ghana.

The first defendant-corporation is the printer of the Ghanaian Times newspaper, a daily Ghanaian publication, and the second defendant is the regional representative of the first defendant-corporation at Sunyani.

On 5 April 1979, the first defendant-corporation is said to have published through its representative, the second defendant, the following statement of and concerning the plaintiff.

“The popular Ananse folk tale ‘You do me, I do you’ is being enacted here by eighteen dismissed workers of the Food Distribution Corporation and the Brong-Ahafo area manager of the corporation, Mr. K. D. Benneh.

The workers had been summarily dismissed, and two others suspended by Mr. Benneh, for flouting his orders to off-load a consignment of 15 bags of rice, following Mr. Benneh’s refusal to give them their staff allocation of one polythene bag of rice each.

Annoyed, the workers swore to expose the ‘illicit rice deals’ by Mr. Benneh. They, therefore reported to the police that he had stolen 15 maxi bags of rice valued at ¢3,600 belonging to the corporation.

When Special Branch men took Mr. Benneh to his hometown, Berekum, last Friday, they found in his house eleven bags suspected to be part of the allegedly stolen fifteen bags. Police have so far not found any documents at the corporation’s offices to show that Mr. Benneh paid for the fifteen bags. They are still investigating the case.

Police sources said, on March 29, the dismissed workers decided not to off-load a consignment of rice which the regional branch of the corporation received until they were assured of one polythene bag each as staff rice allocation. But Mr. Benneh rejected their plea and, in the process dismissed all of them. He also suspended two others on the same day for flouting his orders. Later, Mr. Benneh went to town and recruited labourers to off-load the consignment.

The dismissed workers, not happy with their plight, laid ambush around the offices of the corporation and according to

[p.306] of [1982-83] GLR 302

them found Mr. Benneh loading the rice onto a corporation truck after office hours. They then reported the deal to the Special Branch who arrested Mr. Benneh. The workers are, meanwhile, appealing to management for re-instatement.”

On 12 April 1979, the first defendant-corporation was once more accused of publishing the following statement of and concerning the plaintiff.

“Sunyani police are investigating an alleged diversion of a consignment of twelve barrels of pigfeet by Mr.

K. D. Benneh, Brong-Ahafo Regional Manager of the Food Distribution Corporation. It is alleged that the consignment found its way into the stores of Mr. Benneh’s wives at Berekum.

Mr. Benneh was arrested in the later part of last month for allegedly stealing fifteen bags of rice valued at ¢3,600 belonging to the Corporation. Last Monday, the police acting on a tip-off went to the offices of the corporation here, to study the waybills and other documents which covered the consignment. According to police source, Mr. Benneh was alleged to have diverted the consignment to Berekuin at the corporation’s cost price.

The police have so far interviewed some workers of the corporation including the warehouse keeper on the alleged deal. It is not however known when the docket on Mr. Benneh’s deal would be ready for the police to send him to court. Meanwhile, Mr. Benneh has been suspended indefinitely by the management of the corporation for his alleged involvement in the deal.

COMMITTEE:

A reliable source close to the corporation hinted that Mr. Benneh was expected to appear before the disciplinary committee of the corporation in Accra before the end of the week. Mr. Benneh’s alleged illicit deals at the corporation were exposed by 18 aggrieved workers whom Mr. Benneh, had summarily dismissed for flouting his orders to off-load the consignment of 15 bags of rice following his refusal to give them their staff allocation of one polythene bag of rice each. Police have so far retrieved 11 bags suspected to be part of the 15 bags from Mr. Benneh’s house at Berekum. Available records at the corporation showed that Mr.

Benneh never paid for the 15 bags.”

The plaintiff claims that these two statements are false and that by them his reputation has been injured. Although as libellous statements he need not establish any special damage, the plaintiff claims that by these statements he has suffered special damage, namely that his appointment with the Food Distribution Corporation has been terminated.

[p.307] of [1982-83] GLR 302

The defence simply is that the two statements were fair comment on matters of public interest and that in so far as the facts are concerned they were substantially true. They contend therefore that there was no defamation of the plaintiffs reputation.

The plaintiff gave evidence and called two witnesses in support of his claim. The defen- dants gave no evidence but relied on their pleadings, the plaintiffs own evidence and the law in support of the defence.

The identity of the person about whom the two publications were made is not in dispute. That these publications were made by the second defendant as an agent of the first defendant is also not in dispute. From the publications it is also obvious that the plaintiff was written about in his capacity as the area manager of the Food Distribution Corporation. The Ghana Food Distribution Corporation is a state corporation in which not only the government but also the people of Ghana have an interest. The office of the area manager of this corporation is a public one. Consequently, I find that at the time the publications were made, the plaintiff was holding a public office and performing duties in the interest of the public. To say of a man in the position of the plaintiff that he had stolen bags of rice, I find, is defamatory unless the said statement could be defended in some other way. Also, to say that, the plaintiff, a manager of an establishment had diverted, or stolen either rice or pigfeet which belongs to the corporation, I find, is also defamatory unless this could be defended. The law presumes that the statements are false unless they are proved to be true.

The defence raised consists in the pleas of: (a) fair comment, and (b) justification. It is a good defence to prove that the words complained of are no more than fair and honest comment on a matter of public interest. In Lycon v. Daily Telegraph Ltd. [1943] 1 K.B. 746 at 753, C.A. Scott L.J. observed:

“the right of ‘fair comment’ .is one of the fundamental rights of free speech and writing which are so dear to the British nation, and it is of vital importance to the rule of law on which we depend for our personal freedom.”

Thus, if the facts are truly stated with regard to a matter of public interest, the defendant will succeed in his defence if the jury are satisfied that the comments are fairly and honestly made.

Order 19, r. 23A of the High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1954 (L.N. 140A) provides that:

“23A. Where in an action for libel or slander the defendant alleges that, in so far as the words complained of consist of statements of facts, they are true in substance and in fact, and in

[p.308] of [1982-83] GLR 302

so far as they consist of expressions of opinion, they are fair comment on a matter of public interest, or pleads to the like effect, he shall give particulars stating which of the words complained of he alleges are statements of facts and of the facts and matters he relies on in support of the allegation that the words are true.”

No particulars of the facts and the opinion were pleaded. The defendants however in cross-examination elicited the facts from the plaintiff and his witnesses. The defendants contend further that the facts are already stated in the pleadings of the plaintiff as to make further particulars of facts unnecessary. In fact, in exhibit F, the facts are set down. It was alleged in the publication that the source of the report had come from some dismissed workers. The defendant-corporation only published what is alleged to have been told it. The only comments in this publication are, “Aggrieved Food Distribution Corporation workers expose manager” and “The popular Ananse folk tale ‘You do me, I do you’ is being enacted here by eighteen dismissed workers of the Food Distribution Corporation and the Brong-Ahafo area manager of the corporation, Mr. K. D. Benneh.” And in exhibit G further comments and facts were stated. In this publication not only were the facts of exhibit F repeated, but other allegations were also made, namely the “Food Distribution Corporation Manager in another trouble” and that “the plaintiff allegedly diverted a consignment of 12 barrels of pigfeet.”

For a successful plea of fair comment the words complained of must be shown to be:

(i) Comment.

(ii) Fair in the sense of honest comment.

(iii) Fair comment on a matter of public interest.

A comment, however, is a statement of opinion on facts. The defence does not extend to cover misstatements of fact however bona fide.

The plaintiff in his evidence admitted that there was dismissal of some of his workers. He further admitted that some of these workers made a complaint against him to the police and that upon this complaint the police recovered about eleven bags of rice. He admitted that he had not paid for these. He however explained that in their establishment that could be done. The disciplinary committee before whom he later appeared, it seems, did not agree with this view. The police recovered eleven bags from the plaintiff s house at Berekum and sold these; the amount realised from the sale was paid back to the Food Distribution Corporation. Exhibit H was subsequently written to the plaintiff terminating his appointment. Both the first and the second plaintiff witnesses said there had been these complaints and that as a

[p.309] of [1982-83] GLR 302

result of these eleven bags of rice were retrieved from the plaintiff. The second plaintiff witness stated that these had not been paid for by the plaintiff and the first plaintiff witness agreed that those persons referred to in the publication as having made the statement to the defendants had earlier reported the matter to the police for investigation. Although the first and second plaintiff witnesses do not appear to have detailed knowledge of the complainants and I do not believe in particular all the evidence of the second plaintiff witness who appears to be covering up, I think that what the defendants had stated in the two publications about the plaintiffs involvement in the rice consignment had been a true statement of the facts in the case. I find that in the absence of expressed malice the comments thereon have been fair and honest and the matter being one of public interest, I find the defendants entitled to publish it.

I do not accept however the plea of justification in the circumstances. It could not be said that what the workers had stated and what the defendants had published was true in substance. It could not be said that it has been established that the twelve bags of rice were stolen; what the defendants had published, I find, is a fair comment on facts given them by the workers. These were facts upon which the plaintiff was subsequently called by his superior authorities and dealt with.

I do not find also that the termination of the plaintiff’s appointment had resulted from the publications. The plaintiffs own evidence together with exhibit H clearly shows that his termination had been effected independently of the publications, on an investigation made by the authorities themselves.

It is said that each publication is a separate cause of action. In exhibit G is contained a separate statement of fact involving the plaintiffs illicit dealings with twelve barrels of pigfeet. It is also said that the plea of fair comment does not extend to cover misstatements of facts however bona fide. In other words, the comment must not misstate facts because a comment cannot be fair which is built upon facts which are not truly stated.

In Peter Walker & Son Ltd. v. Hodgson [1909] 1 K.B. 239 Kennedy J said at 256:

“where the words which are alleged to be defamatory allege, or assume as true, facts concerning the plaintiff which the plaintiff denies, and which either involve a slanderous imputation in themselves, or upon which the comment bases imputations or inferences injurious to the plaintiff, it is, I think settled law that the defence of fair comment fails, unless the comment is truthful in regard to its allegation or assumption of such facts.”

[p.310] of [1982-83] GLR 302

In Davis v. Shepstone (1886) 11 App.Cas. 187, P.C. the appellants published in their newspaper serious allegations with reference to official conduct of the respondent, who was the Resident Commissioner in Zululand. They alleged that he had not only himself violently assaulted a Zulu chief, but had set on his native policemen to assault others. On the assumption that these statements were true, they commented upon his conduct in terms of great severity. At the trial it was proved that the allegations were without foundations, and no attempt was made to support them by evidence. The jury found a verdict for the plaintiff with £500 damages, and this verdict was upheld on appeal both by the Supreme Court of Natal and the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. In the course of their judgment their lordships said at p. 190:

“There is no doubt that the public acts of a public man may lawfully be made the subject of fair comment or criticism, not only by the press, but by all members of the public. But the distinction cannot be too clearly borne in mind between comment or criticism and allegations of fact, such as that disgraceful acts have been committed . . . It is one thing to comment upon or criticise, even with severity, the acknowledged or proved acts of a public man, and quite another to assert that he has been guilty of particular acts of misconduct.”

The defendants made no effort to prove the allegation concerning the pigfeet contained in exhibit G. Although an attempt was made to get some evidence on the pigfeet issue through cross-examination, the plaintiff denied this and tendered in evidence exhibits C1—C4 and D1—D4 to show that the pigfeet had been properly obtained. Exhibit H made no reference to pigfeet. The first plaintiff witness’ evidence and exhibit A did not speak of pigfeet. In fact, it is not known from what source the defendants had obtained this fact. No witness was called by the defendants to establish this allegation. The police had never investigated any allegation on the pigfeet. The evidence on record overwhelmingly shows that the allegation about the pigfeet is unfounded. I find therefore that the statement upon which the defendants commented was a misstatement of fact and since it has not been established as true, the comment on it could not be fair. It was for the defendants to establish this plea and since they failed to do so, I hold that the statement on the pigfeet concerning the plaintiff was defamatory, even though it was published as having been alleged.

The defendants cannot avail themselves of the plea of justification, they having failed to establish the truth of the facts stated by them. I find therefore that by their second publication, the defendants did cast a slur on the reputation of the plaintiff as the then area manager of the Food Distribution Corporation.

[p.311] of [1982-83] GLR 302

The plaintiff need not establish any special damage to be entitled to an award of damages. Although I have found that the termination of the plaintiffs appointment was not the result of these publications, I think by the defamatory statement the plaintiff has greatly suffered. The plaintiff was at the time of the publication the area manager; he is also a royal. Despite efforts to get the defendants to retract the statement, they failed to do so. The defendants must therefore bear the consequences of their own act. To say of the plaintiff that he had diverted or hoarded or stolen pigfeet consigned to his establishment was a very serious allegation. It did not matter that this allegation was contained in a publication part of which was a fair comment, this piece of evidence was evidently calculated to damage the plaintiffs reputation. In conclusion I give judgment for the plaintiff and award him ¢20,000 damages against the defendants jointly and severally. He is also awarded ¢2,000 costs.

DECISION Judgment for the plaintiff.

J. A. A.

Scroll to Top