SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1982] SLR (HC) 6High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL II)

BOYE vs. ACHIMOTA BREWERY COMPANY LIMITED [1982-83] GLR 955

12 November 1982 · HAYFRON J · ≈ 10 min read

Cite as[1982] SLR (HC) 6
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLABOYE v ACHIMOTA BREWERY COMPANY LIMITED [1982-83] GLR 955 [1982] SLR (HC) 6
APABOYE v ACHIMOTA BREWERY COMPANY LIMITED [1982-83] GLR 955, [1982] SLR (HC) 6 (Ghana).
BluebookBOYE v ACHIMOTA BREWERY COMPANY LIMITED [1982-83] GLR 955, [1982] SLR (HC) 6 (Ghana High Ct. 1982).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASES REFERRED TO

(1) Morris v. Baron & Co. [1918] A.C. 1; 87 L.J.K.B. 162, 118 L.T. 34, H.L.

(2) Royal Exchange Assurance v. Hope [1928] Ch. 179; 97 L.J. Ch. 153; 138 L.T. 446; 44 T.L.R. 160, C.A.

(3) Berry v. Berry [1929] 2 K.B. 316; 98 L.J.K.B. 748; 141 L.T. 461, 45 T.L.R. 524.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

ACTION by the plaintiff against the defendants for, inter alia, damages for breach of contract. The facts are sufficiently set out in the judgment.

COUNSEL

Adumua-Bossman for the plaintiff-applicant.

Ofosu-Asante for the defendant-respondent.

JUDGMENT OF HAYFRON J.

On 26 May 1981, the plaintiff, Emmanuel Adjetey Boye, wrote to the Achimota Brewery Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the defendant-company) offering to have manufactured for them 1,000 pieces printed cartons together with fitments at a cost of ¢1,725. That letter is not an exhibit in this application but on 27 May 1981 the defendant-company acting per their procurement manager, N. E. Mensah, wrote the letter, exhibit EAB1, directed to the Managing Director, Angels Sing Company, P. O. Box 10882, Accra-North. That letter reads:

“Dear Sir, SUPPLY OF ABC CARTONS AND FITMENTS This is to confirm our acceptance of your quotations for printed ABC outer cartons with fitments, reference your AS.11/321 dated 26 May 1981 given below:

1,000 pieces printed cartons @ ¢1,350 1,000 fitments @ ¢375 Delivery cost of 1,000 complete cartons @ ¢1,725 Total volume of order 100,000 pieces 100,000 pieces Total cost of order 172,500 TERMS: 50 per cent deposit payment — ¢86,250 (Our cheque No. 350403/166724 of 27 May 1981)

Delivery period for 50,000 pieces — End of June 1981.

Delivery period of balance — End of July 1981.

[p.957] of [1982-83] GLR 955 Payment of balance of 86,250 on delivery of balance of 50,000 pieces.

As a guide in selection of suppliers and paper quality, please find below the following information obtained from Paper Conversion Corporation, our local suppliers of beer cartons.

SPECIFICATIONS AND ADDRESSES OF SUPPLIERS OF PAPER TO P.C.C. TAKORADI 1. ELOF HANSON 2. GOTHIA PULP 7 PAPER AE S – 41327 P. O. Box 2515 GOTEBORG – SWEDEB S. – 403 17 GOTHENBURG – SWEDEN (a) Unbleached Kraft Liner (b) First Class Semi-Chemical Real Width – 64” Fluting Specifications— Diameter – 50” same as in (a)

CORE – 4”

Substance – 200 & 150 gm² . . . delivery dates will be highly appreciated.

Yours faithfully, for Achimota Brewery Co., Ltd.

(Sgd.)

Procurement Manager”

The total volume of the order thereby placed was 100,000 pieces at a total cost of ¢172,500 on these terms: (a) that 50 per cent of the cost was to be paid as a deposit and (b) that 50,000 pieces pieces were to be delivered at the end of June 1981; the balance to be delivered at the end of July 1981, upon which the balance of the cost was to be paid to the plaintiff.

On 27 May 1981, the date of exhibit EAB1, the defendant-company sent to the plaintiff a cheque for ¢86,250 being 50 per cent of the total cost of the order as a deposit payment. Some time later, the plaintiff presented to the defendant-company a sample-carton. Thereafter the two parties entered upon discussions which resulted in modifications to the cartons. And on 11 June 1981, the defendant-company wrote to the plaintiff the letter exhibit EAB2. That letter reads:

[p.958] of [1982-83] GLR 955 “Dear Sir, ABC BEER CARTONS (PRINTED)

I refer to the sample-carton you presented and the subsequent discussions, and have to confirm and draw your attention on the following modifications as agreed:

(1) HORIZONTAL SIDE OF THE CARTON

(a) The edges of the printed ABC in red must be checked and properly printed.

(b) The size of the barley leaves design including the printed inserted ABC letters in red must be reduced by about 25 per cent.

(c) The position of the printed barley leaves and the inserted ABC letters in red must be shifted down (about Two Inches).

Your fullest co-operation and prompt reaction would be appreciated.

Yours faithfully, (Sgd.) W. A. Attafuah (Gen Brands Manager)”

The letter dealt only with the modifications to the carton. That same day the defendant-company issued a local purchase order which called on the plaintiff to supply to them 500,000 cartons together with fitments at a total cost of ¢862,500. This order is marked exhibit AEB3.

It is noticeable that the defendant-company did not recall the payment of the ¢86,250 nor did they make up the ¢431,250 being 50 per cent of the cost of the order placed. On 29th July 1982, the plaintiff issued a specially indorsed writ claiming as per the indorsement:

“1. On 27th May 1981 the plaintiff entered into an agreement with the defendant for the supply by the plaintiff to the defendant of 100,000 units of printed cartons and fitments for the packaging of ABC beer for sale.

[p.959] of [1982-83] GLR 955

2. Thereupon, by Ghana Commercial Bank crossed cheque No. 350403/166724 drawn on its High Street Branch, Accra, the defendant paid to the plaintiff the sum of ¢86,250 on account of an initial deposit of ¢172,500 and requested and obtained from the plaintiff time to pay the deposit balance of ¢86,250 due under the said agreement.

3. The plaintiff thereafter travelled abroad and placed the execution of the work with his foreign business agents who for their part produced prototype cartons which the plaintiff brought back to Ghana and submitted for the inspection and approval of the defendant. The defendant’s board thereupon suggested various design changes in the appearance of the prototype carton, and the plaintiff agreed to all the said changes on 11 June 1981.

4. Still on 11 June 1981 the said agreement was novated by increasing the quantities to be supplied to 500,000 cartons and 500,00 fitments for an aggregate price of ¢862,500. By reason of the said novation the initial deposit balance became ¢345,250 immediately due and owing to the plaintiff under the said novated agreement.

5. Later, in performance of his part of the said novated agreement, the plaintiff caused his foreign business agents abroad to commence production of the redesigned cartons and the fitments.

6. The defendant has refused or failed thus far in breach of the said novated agreement to pay the said initial deposit balance of ¢345,000 and thereby committed a breach of the whole agreement novated as aforesaid.

7. The plaintiff who is ready to perform his part of the said novated agreement therefore claims ¢776,250 damages for breach thereof with interest at the Bank of Ghana rate of 17 1/2 per cent per annum from June 1979 to 31 August 1981 and thereafter at the same bank’s rate of 25 1/2 per cent per annum until judgment.”

Six days later, i.e. 4 August 1982, the defendant-company entered appearance. When after a month the defendant-company had done nothing more the plaintiff suedour a summons for judgment on 6 September 1982. This summons was supported by an affidavit in which the plaintiff stated that the defendant company had no defence to his claim.

The very next day the defendant-company woke up with an affidavit in opposition to judgment being entered against them. That

[p.960] of [1982-83] GLR 955 affidavit denied he plaintiffs claim that the defendant-company were indebted to the plaintiff by reason of their breach of the novated agreement for supplying printed cardboard cartons with fitments. They also denied that they agreed to make up 50 per cent of the order placed but that the deposit already paid was to stand as a ten per cent deposit of the total price. The deponent to that affidavit referred to a letter, exhibit 1, which he says he wrote to the plaintiff on 22 January 1982. In that letter it was stated that the defendant-company had paid the plaintiff ten per cent of the total value of order as deposit. It also threatened legal action which did not materialise. The defendant-company finally sought to put blame on the plaintiff for what they described as his failure to honour his promise “on which you made us rely so much to our utter disappointment.”

Mr Ofosu-Asante, counsel for the defendant-company, contended first that exhibit EAB3 which is the final agreement between the parties did not mention novation. Exhibit EAB3 could not be the final agreement between the parties unless of course the parties had agreed to rescind the first agreement as contained in exhibit EAB1. This they had not done. This exhibit EAB1 contained the terms of the agreement between the parties which was in writing. What I understand the parties to have done was to alter some of the terms of that agreement by substituting a newly designed carton for the one originally agreed upon. This alteration was subsequently put in writing in exhibit EAB2 as quoted above.

Of course the parties to a contract may effect a variation of the contract by modifying or altering its terms by mutual agreement: see Royal Exchange Assurance v. hope [1928] Ch. 179, C.A. and Berry v. Berry [1929] 2 K.B. 316. When this happens the contract arrived at is the original contract with the variation or modification written in place of the term that is varied or modified. There is no new contract but the original one. Exhibit EAB2 was not a new and separate contract. The alteration was subsidiary to the main purpose of the contract as it stood originally — the sale and purchase of beer cartons. That was not changed. Exhibit EAB2 by mentioning “modification” can only be referring to the contract as evidenced by exhibit EAB1 which was the agreement in the minds of the parties at the time of the discussions the results of which were embodied in exhibit EAB2. Exhibit EAB3 on which Mr Ofosu Asante put such heavy reliance bears the same date as exhibit EAB2 and is an order to the plaintiff to “supply ABC cartons and fitments.” What cartons and fitments? Obviously the cartons and fitments the purchase and sale of which had already been embodied in the agreement between the parties as contained in exhibits EAB1 and 2. Apart from raising the number from 100,000 to 500,000 that exhibit does not mention any other

[p.961] of [1982-83] GLR 955 terms. This is only because the other terms of the contract had already been agreed. If that were not the understanding, exhibit EAB3 would be vague. In exhibits EAB1 and 2 were indicated the two types of cartons involved in the negotiations between the parties. Which ones were the plaintiff to supply? The type agreed upon as in exhibit EAB1 or the type agreed upon as in exhibit EAB2? That order would only make business sense if it is related to the cartons agreed to be sold as described in exhibit EAB2 which is itself a variation of the contract as evidenced in exhibit EAB1. In my judgment the argument is unmeritorious.

Mr Ofosu-Asante’s second argument was that the action was not brought in good faith because when the defendant-company wrote to the plaintiff in January 1982, the plaintiff did not write to say that he had not delivered because the defendant-company had not paid the deposit. He contended that it was for the plaintiff to inform the defendant-company of the amount of deposit payable consequent upon the increased order.

It appears to me strange that a limited liability company with a list of eight directors, several managers, an accountant and having the services of a solicitor, should expect the plaintiff who conducts his business under the fanciful name of “Angels Sing” to write to inform them of their obligation under a contract into which they have entered.

Had they consulted their lawyer in this matter they would not have found themselves in their present predicament. The payment of the deposit was a term of the contract. They now seek to say that it was agreed that the original payment should serve as a ten per cent deposit for the delivery of the cartons. If that were so I have no doubt it would have been mentioned in exhibit EAB2 which was written as a result of the discussions which the parties had after exhibit EAB1.

Mr Ofosu-Asante also contended that by the subsequent agreement the original contract was annulled and all the terms and conditions fell and the parties should have agreed on new terms as the old terms were no longer binding. He said the parties were not ad idem as to the terms to be attached to the order contained in exhibit EAB3.

If that were the intention of the defendant-company then as was said in Morris v. Baron & Co. [1918] A.C. 1 at p. 19, H.L.

“. . . there should have been made manifest the intention in any event of a complete extinction of the first and formal contract, and not merely the desire of an alteration, however sweeping in terms which leave it still subsisting.”

The contract was one for the sale and purchase of printed beer cartons and “if the changes do not go to the root of the contract” there is merely a variation. This variation was bound to cause some delay in [p.962] of [1982-83] GLR 955 delivery. Having failed to pay the 50 per cent deposit which was the signal for the plaintiff to deliver, the defendant-company were in breach of the contract and could not be heard to complain of the non-delivery.

From the foregoing, it is my judgment that the defendant-company have no defence to the plaintiff’s claim.

The plaintiff however maintains that the new cartons have ben manufactured and he is ready to deliver them. I shall therefore give judgment in the following terms:

(a) The defendant-company will pay to the plaintiff the sum of ¢86,250 as damages for the breach of contract.

(b) Within two weeks of today the defendant-company shall pay to the plaintiff the sum of ¢345,250 to make up the 50 per cent deposit.

(c) Within six weeks of such payment the plaintiff shall deliver 50 per cent of the order so placed. (d) Within six weeks thereafter the plaintiff shall deliver the remaining 50 per cent of the said order; and (e) Upon such delivery the defendant-company shall pay to the plaintiff the sum of ¢431,500. The plaintiff will have his costs of ¢8,625 inclusive of fee to counsel.

DECISION Judgment for the plaintiff with costs.

M. C. N.N.

Scroll to Top