SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1979] SLR (HC) 77High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1981

DORYUMU vs. NANOR-AGBOZO [1981] GLR 311

26 April 1979 · MENSA BOISON J · ≈ 6 min read

Cite as[1979] SLR (HC) 77
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLADORYUMU v NANOR-AGBOZO [1981] GLR 311 [1979] SLR (HC) 77
APADORYUMU v NANOR-AGBOZO [1981] GLR 311, [1979] SLR (HC) 77 (Ghana).
BluebookDORYUMU v NANOR-AGBOZO [1981] GLR 311, [1979] SLR (HC) 77 (Ghana High Ct. 1979).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASES REFERRED TO

(1) Orr Ewing, In re; Orr Ewing v. Orr Ewing (1882) 22 Ch. D. 456; 52 L.J.Ch. 529; 48 L.T. 555; 31 W.R. 464, C.A. on appeal, sub nom. Ewing v. Orr Ewing (1883) 9 App. Cas. 34, H.L.

(2) Preston v. Lamont (1876) 1 Ex.D. 361; 45 L.J.Q.B. 797; 35 L.T. 341; 40 J.P. 745; 34 W.R. 928.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPLICATION by the defendant to set aside the issue and service of’ a writ of summons under Order 12, r. 24 of’ L.N. 140A. The facts are fully set out in the ruling.

COUNSEL

Dr. Ekow Daniels for the applicant.

B. E. Kwaw-Swanzy for the respondent.

JUDGMENT OF MENSA BOISON J.

The defendant by counsel moves the court to have the plaintiff’s writ of summons struck out as disclosing no cause of action. By that writ the plaintiff claims for a declaration

[p.313] of [1981] GLR 311

that the defendant’s election as a council held on 17 November 1978 was void.

The defendant’s motion follows an entry of conditional appearance or appearance under protest. That is said to be by virtue of Order 12, r. 24 of the High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1954 (L.N. 140A), which provides:

“24. A defendant before appearing shall be at liberty, without obtaining an order to enter or entering a conditional appearance, to take out a summons or serve notice of motion to set aside the service upon

him of the writ or of notice of the writ, or to discharge the order authorising such service.”

Mr. Kwaw-Swanzy for the plaintiff, contests the propriety of the motion. He submits that the applicant is out of court, since Order 12, r. 24 applies only to motions before entering appearance albeit conditional or under protest. Consequently although the applicant purported to enter a conditional appearance, the effect it is contended, is that the appearance is deemed to be in unconditional appearance and any objections as taken by the motion may only be taken as objections in law under Order 25, r. 2.

Dr. Ekow Daniels, counsel for the applicant, was certain he was not praying in aid any practice under the English Rules, Order 12, rr. 7 and 8, which Mr. Kwaw-Swanzy expatiated from the 1967 edition of the English Annual Practice which differed with his interpretation of Order 12, r. 24. The sidenote to Order 12, r. 24 shows the English equivalent to be Order 12, r. 30. In the English Annual Practice (1962 ed.), Order 12, r. 30 is stated at p. 198 in all material particulars as our rule 24 as follows:

“A defendant before appearing shall be at liberty, without obtaining an order to enter or entering a conditional appearance, to take out a summons in the Queen’s Bench Division and in any other Division take out a summons or serve notice of motion to set aside the service upon him of the writ or of notice of the writ, or to discharge the order authorising such service.”

The commentator’s notes at the same page 198 show that the phrase “before appearing” means “before entering an unconditional appearance.” I would paraphrase Order 12, r. 24 thus:

That a defendant may take out a summons or serve notice of motion to set aside the writ, etc., in any of these three situations:

(a) before entering an unconditional appearance; or

(b) after entering a conditional appearance without leave of the court; or (c) without entering a conditional appearance.

[p.314] of [1981] GLR 311

The object of the rule is not to prejudice the position of a defendant who intends to object to the issue or service of the writ. Speaking of entering an appearance the learned author of Odger’s Principles of Pleading (15th ed.) at p. 12 states:

“If the defendant wished to defend the action, he must enter an appearance,’ unless there is some irregularity in the issue or service of the writ, in which case he may enter a ‘conditional appearance’ and move to set it aside, he may indeed do so before entering an appearance. (Order XIII rule 30).”

Again at p. 199 of the Annual Practice (1962 ed.), the commentator commenting on Order 12, r. 30 notes:

“The term ‘conditional appearance’ means an appearance in qualified terms, reserving to the appearing defendant the right to apply to the Court to set aside the writ, or service thereof, for an alleged informality or irregularity which renders either the writ or service invalid or for lack of jurisdiction.”

Yet again in Halsbury’s Laws of England (2nd ed.) at p. 36 dealing with setting aside a writ or service under the English Order 12, r. 30, it is stated:

“If the writ is irregular, the defendant may obtain an order setting it aside; or if service has been irregular, the defendant may, before appearance, apply for an order setting aside the service of the writ or notice of the writ.”

And in footnote (f) at p. 36 (supra) on the said Order 12, r. 30, the point is made that “The application may be made without entering a conditional appearance, or obtaining an order therefor.”

On the strength of the above statements of the law I hold that the defendant’s notice of motion under Order 12, r. 24 is well-founded, and need not require leave to file. It is well-founded because the law is that after unconditional appearance, it is too late to object to any irregularity in the service or issue of the writ of which the defendant had knowledge; for appearance is a “fresh step” under Order 70, r. 2: see In re Orr Ewing; Orr Ewing v. Orr Ewing (1883) 22 Ch.D 456, C.A. To say, as urged by Mr. Kwaw-Swanzy, that the applicant should take the objections in the defence and have them heard under Order 25, r. 2, would be to prejudice the objections of the defendant. Since the objections complain of irregularity in the issue of the writ, the law is that the irregularities cannot be pleaded by the defendant after an unconditional appearance: see Preston v. Lamont (1876) 1 Ex.D. 361.

[p.315] of [1981] GLR 311

The objections raised by the motion are:

1. That the plaintiff’s writ falls foul of paragraph 27 of the Representation of the People Decree, 1968 (N.L.C.D. 255), which prescribes that the validity of an election can only be questioned by a petition.

2. That by paragraph 30 of N.L.C.D. 255 an election petition can only be brought within 21 days after the date of publication in the gazette of the results.

The plaintiff filed his writ on 14 December 1978 well ahead of the publication of the result in the Ghana Gazette (No. 64 of 1978) at p. 1027 on Wednesday 22 December 1978. The above two grounds in my opinion constitute irregularities in the issue of the writ; the first affecting the form of action and the second having the effect that no cause of action had accrued at the date of the issue of the writ.

Although the English Order 12, r. 30 speaks of “motion to set aside the service upon him [defendant] of the writ or notice of the writ or to discharge the order authorising such service,” it seems the rule applies to cases where there is irregularity in the issue of the writ because setting aside of a writ is not limited to specific grounds.

Mr. Kwaw-Swanzy has not answered to the merits of the objections and for the reasons I have given above, I am obliged to set aside the issue and service of the writ herein upon the defendant. There will be costs of ¢600 for the defendant.

DECISION Application upheld.

Issue and service of writ set aside.

D. F. L.

Scroll to Top