GYEBI AND ANOTHER vs. ADUHENE [1981] GLR 777
29 October 1981 · TWUMASI J · ≈ 4 min read
[1981] SLR (HC) 6Other citation styles and permanent link
SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS
APPLICATION for an order setting aside a previous decision of the court to allow twenty-three persons to be joined as defendants in a land suit. The facts are sufficiently set out in the ruling.
COUNSEL
Atua for the applicants.
Damptey for the respondent.
JUDGMENT OF TWUMASI J.
The defendants pray this court to vacate its previous decision to allow the plaintiff to join twenty-three more persons as defendants to this action. Mr. Atua, counsel for the defendants, argued that the motion for joinder was incompetent inasmuch as it was made ex parte. Mr. Damptey, counsel for the plaintiff, relied on Order 15, r. 10 of the High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1954
[p.779] of [1981] GLR 777
(L.N. 140A), as substituted by the High Court (Civil Procedure) (Amendment) (No. 2) Rules, 1977 (L.I. 1129), and submitted that under the rules, an application to join a person in possession of land could be made ex parte. Upon a careful study of Order 15, r. 10, I fail to accept Mr. Damptey’s argument. It seems to me that Order 15, r. 10 in so far as it permits applications ex parte, applies only to cases where a party in possession of a land which is the subject-matter of the suit applies to be joined as a defendant in order to protect his interest. But where a plaintiff desires to seek an order of the court to join any party as a defendant, it is imperative that the application be made on notice to the defendants. This is especially so where the trial has advanced to a far extent that the joinder may inure to embarrass the defendants or delay the trial to the detriment of the defendants in terms of expenditure of time, energy and money. Indeed, the main reason why Mr. Atua sought an order of this court to set aside its order to join twenty-three persons as defendants was that the trial would be unduly delayed. I entirely share Mr. Atua’s view. Order 15, r. 5 (1) provides:
“5. (1) If claims in respect of two or more causes of action are included by a plaintiff in the same action or by a defendant in a counterclaim, or if two or more plaintiffs or defendants are parties to the same action, and it appears to the Court that the joinder of causes of action or of parties, as the case may be may embarrass or delay the trial or is otherwise inconvenient, the Court may— (a) order separate trials; or… (b) prevent a defendant from being embarrassed or put to expense by being required to
attend proceedings in which he has no interest; or
(c) make such other order as may be expedient.”
In view of this discretionary power given to the court which in this case can be exercised in a manner that would be fair to both parties, I would decide that the application ex parte be treated as valid so that the plaintiff be permitted to join as many defendants as he may wish to sue, but the court would order that the plaintiff pursue his case against the original defendants separate from his case against the new defendants. My reason for ordering separate trials was based on the fact that the plaintiff has called no less than five witnesses each of whom gave copious evidence. There is no doubt that considerable time, energy and money have been consumed by the parties. What is more, the issues involved in the case are such that the joinder of the twenty-three persons would embarrass the defendants. The plaintiff’s case is that the defendants are in [p.780] of [1981] GLR 777 breach of a tenancy agreement by sub-leasing portions of land leased to them to the twenty-three persons to be joined as defendants. If the case against all the defendants is tried together, the original defendants will not benefit adequately from their right to cross-examine the other defendants. For these reasons, I would refuse the application to set aside the order joining the twenty-three persons as defendants but order that their case be deferred to the end of the original suit. No order as to costs. Original case to proceed. Adjourned to 30 November 1981 for continuation.
DECISION Application refused on terms.
J. K. E. E.
