SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1982] SLR (HC) 15High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL II)

OFORI-ATTA vs. DUODU [1982-83] GLR 1094

25 August 1982 · ASARE-KWAPONG J · ≈ 15 min read

Cite as[1982] SLR (HC) 15
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAOFORI-ATTA v DUODU [1982-83] GLR 1094 [1982] SLR (HC) 15
APAOFORI-ATTA v DUODU [1982-83] GLR 1094, [1982] SLR (HC) 15 (Ghana).
BluebookOFORI-ATTA v DUODU [1982-83] GLR 1094, [1982] SLR (HC) 15 (Ghana High Ct. 1982).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASES REFERRED TO

(1) Tuowa v. Apontua (1914) D.C.A.L. 38.

(2) Owiah v. Biya (1940) D.C. (Land) 38-47, 71.

[p.1095] of [1982-83] GLR 1094

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

ACTION by the plaintiff for ejectment and recovery of possession of a house devised to her, and an account of all rents collected by the defendant from the tenants occupying the said house. The facts are sufficiently set out in the judgment.

COUNSEL

Kye for the plaintiff.

Defendant in person.

JUDGMENT OF ASARE-KWAPONG J.

In this case the plaintiff’s claim against the defendant is for:

1. ejectment and recovery of possession of house No. W. 114/4, Kibi, which has been bequeathed to the plaintiff and her children by Opanin Kofi Pobi deceased, and 2. account of rents collected by the defendant from all the tenants who occupy the said house. In the statement of claim accompanying the writ of summons the plaintiff alleged the following particulars of her claim:

“1. By virtue of a devise made in the will of the late Kofi Pobi, the plaintiff and her children became the beneficiaries of house No. W. 114/4 in which the defendant lives at Kibi.

2. The said testator died on 12 November 1979 and probate of his will granted on 25 September 1980.

3. The plaintiff applied to the High Court, Accra, jointly with one of the executors named in the will and probate was accordingly granted to them.

4. The testator, who was the father of the defendant and brother of the plaintiff under paragraph 4 (1) of the will expressly gifted his said house to the plaintiff for life and after her death to all the children of the plaintiff.

5. The contents of the said will have been made known to members of the family of the testator including his children.

6. The defendant has failed or neglected to surrender the house to the plaintiff despite repeated demands.

7. Meanwhile, the defendant has been collecting rents from all the tenants in the house without accounting to the plaintiff who is lawfully entitled to receive same.”

The defendant in his defence denied the plaintiff’s claim generally and averred in paragraph 4 of his defence that a caveat was filed in the High Court Registry, Accra, on 8 October 1980 to prohibit the grant of probate to the plaintiff. He further averred in paragraphs 6 – 8 as follows:

[p.1096] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 “6. The defendant admits that the alleged testator was his father and a brother of the plaintiff but denies the rest of paragraph 4 of the statement of claim.

7. In further explanation of paragraph 4 of the statement of claim the defendant contends that the said H/No. W.114/4, Kibi, was gifted to him and his brothers by his father Kofi Pobi (deceased) in

September 1974 in the presence of witnesses including members of the deceased’s family.

8. The defendant says that after the customary gift of the said house, ¢16 (aseda) and a bottle of schnapps was presented by the children to the said Kofi Pobi (deceased) in the presence of witnesses.”

Before pleadings were closed the plaintiff filed a motion on notice in this court praying for an order of interim injunction restraining the defendant or his agents from collecting rents from tenants in H/No. W.114/4, Kibi, and for the appointment of a manager-receiver of the said rents until the hearing and determination of the suit. This motion was accompanied by an affidavit sworn to by the plaintiff justifying this motion. The defendant on the other hand swore to an affidavit in opposition to the plaintiff’s motion stating among other facts that, “Part of this amount is used for the maintenance and education of the minors among my brothers who are now attending middle schools at Kibi.” Since this allegation was refuted by the plaintiff that the defendant was not looking after any such minors and also that the plaintiff in her writ of summons was asking for “account of rents collected by the defendant from all the tenants who occupy the said house” I granted the application for interim injunction and appointed a receiver-manager to collect the rents.

At the close of pleadings the following issues were set down for hearing:

(a) Whether or not the late Kofi Pobi made a devise of H/No. W.114/4, Kibi to the plaintiff and her children in his will.

(b) Whether or not the customary will in respect of H/No. W.114/4, Kibi, made in favour of the defendant and his brothers in September 1974 by their deceased father was revoked by the testator during his lifetime.

(c) Whether or not the High Court has lawfully granted probate of the will to the plaintiff and another executor.

The first plaintiff witness, in his evidence, told the court that he once lived in the house in dispute together with the defendant. In about 1974 the deceased made him to understand that after his (deceased’s) death his children should take the house as a gift. Later, however, the deceased realised that the defendant and the other

[p.1097] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 children were showing some disrespect to him. The deceased eventually left for Accra for medical treatment. While in Accra, the deceased wrote a letter, exhibit B, to the defendant, which letter the defendant showed to him. When the deceased returned from Accra to Kibi, he called him (witness) to his room one day. He met the wife of the deceased, one Kwame Asirifi, the second plaintiff witness in this case, and one Atta Ofori.

The children of the deceased brought two half sizes of schnapps and the defendant announced that the schnapps together with a sheep were being brought to the deceased as aseda for the gift of the house. He said he never saw the sheep. He testified that the deceased refused to take the drinks in view of exhibit B. When the deceased died, he left the house.

The second plaintiff witness who described himself as a bosom friend of the deceased told the court that he lived in Accra, but sometimes when he went to Kibi he slept in the house of the deceased. He said on one such visit there was an arbitration to which he was invited. At the arbitration the deceased told him that his children had offered him two half sizes of schnapps as aseda in appreciation of the gift of the house to them; a gift which the children were to take after his death. He stated that at the arbitration were the first plaintiff witness, the defendant, the wife of the deceased and others. He said the deceased refused to take the aseda in their presence, saying that he had revoked it because the children had insulted him that there was no sense in his big head. Further that the children did not take him to the hospital when he was ill. He said he left for Accra but when the deceased later went to Accra he told him (witness) that he had changed his mind.

The plaintiff in her evidence stated that the deceased was her brother. On 12 November 1979, the deceased died. After his death, she got to know that he had deposited a will at the High Court, Accra. She and one Kwadwo Nyarko applied for probate which was granted on 25 September 1980. A certified true copy of the will was tendered in evidence as exhibit A. Since the death of her brother, the defendant had been living in the house collecting rents from the tenants until an injunction was granted appointing a receiver and manager. The defendant has since refused to give up the house to her.

One Yaw Mensah who once lived in the house in dispute was the third plaintiff witness. He told the court that while living there, there were ten other tenants who paid various rents. He himself was paying ¢12 per month and he gave the names of the tenants and the amount each person was paying, namely Messrs. Ebenezer, Okyere, Danso and Amoah—¢32 per month; Messrs. Attah, Opoku and Miss Otubea—¢15 per month; Ellen—¢20 per month; Sgt. Lydia (store) ¢35 per month; Pat ¢25 per month and he was paying ¢12 per month.

[p.1098] of [1982-83] GLR 1094

The fourth plaintiff witness, the executor of the will of the late Kofi Pobi, told the court in his evidence that the deceased was his younger brother. He said during his lifetime the family met in 1974 and the deceased told them at the family meeting that he was going to give the house in dispute to the children, so that when he died the children would take it. The deceased stamped the gift with one bottle of schnapps. Later, however, the deceased informed him that he had asked a lawyer, by name Bob Ananey, to write to the children revoking the gift as they had insulted him.

Pobi died later and he went to Accra to obtain probate of his will, he being the executor. In the box of the deceased he came across exhibit B by which the deceased brother revoked the gift. He finally stated that since the grant of the probate, he had not handed over the house to the plaintiff as the defendant is contending that the house has been gifted to him and the other children.

The defendant in his evidence told the court that during the lifetime of the deceased he married four wives and had ten children. He gifted the house in dispute to all the children and the aseda to be paid to the deceased was also divided into four, representing the wives. He said the gift was made to the children in the presence of the family in 1974 and that they paid aseda of ¢16 and a bottle of schnapps to the deceased; however, they could not provide the sheep before the deceased was taken ill and so he could not receive the sheep. He died later.

He denied that he received exhibit B revoking the gift and said that only two of the tenants in the house were paying rents. The rest of the tenants being children of the deceased, were not paying rents. He collected rents from the two tenants which he used to repair the building. On cross-examination, however, he admitted that there were eleven tenants in the house as stated by the third plaintiff witness.

The first defendant witness, Kwesi Kune, testified to the effect that the deceased was his elder brother, when he was alive he gifted the house in dispute to the children and the children gave him an aseda of ¢16 and a bottle of schnapps. He admitted that he once lived in the house in dispute but he was ejected and as a customary successor, he was shocked when the will of the late Pobi was read apparently because he did not get anything as a successor. He also admitted that as Akim Abuakwa custom demanded, the children should have provided a sheep to the deceased when he made the gift, but this was not done before he died. He finally admitted that the gift would take effect after the death of the late Pobi. The last witness called by the defendant was Afua Fofie, a cousin of the deceased. She confirmed that the house in dispute was gifted to the defendant and the other children. The children paid aseda of ¢16 and a bottle of

[p.1099] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 schnapps but did not provide a live sheep. She also admitted that she was ejected from the house in dispute.

By paragraph 4 of his will, probate of which was granted on 25 September 1980, the late Kofi Pobi stated as follows:

“I devise and bequeath to my sister Gladys Rose Oforiwa (alias Mrs. Rose Ofori-Atta) for her life, and after her death, to ALL HER CHILDREN, jointly and absolutely, the following properties, namely:

(i) My real property being my compound house situate at Kibi.”

There were other bequests but for the purpose of the present case, I shall mention the above devise, being the matter in controversy.

After the grant of the probate on 25 September 1980, the defendant filed a caveat on 8 October 1980 and according to paragraph 4 of the defence “to prohibit the grant of probate to the plaintiff.” Whether this caveat was pursued or not, is not known to the court because no evidence was forthcoming on its conclusion. In any case the caveat has no relevance in this court since it was not filed here at Koforidua.

As counsel rightly pointed out in his address, the defendant could pursue the caveat at the appropriate forum. I will hereby digress from my course to comment on the filing of an application for probate or administration. It may be in force for three months only from the date of filing, but it may be renewed from time to time. I cannot surmise why the defendant did not pursue the caveat up till now. In any case this does not detract from the present case as stated above.

The defendant further resisted this claim by contending that the house in dispute was gifted to him and his brothers by his father, the late Kofi Pobi in September 1974 in the presence of witnesses including members of the deceased’s family. If this is the case then the plaintiff’s claim is misconceived; but in reaching such a conclusion the court must go further to find out whether the gift made to the defendant and his brothers was a gift inter vivos or a conditional customary gift. What constitutes a valid gift inter vivos as claimed by the defendant? In Tuowa v. Appontua (1914) D.C.A.L. 38 it was held that the fact that the gift was made in the presence of accredited witnesses and the plaintiff paid aseda was sufficient to prove the validity of the gift. But is this instant case the same as the above cited case? It has similarities with it in so far as aseda was alleged to have been made by the defendant by payment of ¢16 and a bottle of schnapps; but the most important item was not provided, that is a sheep. The significance of a sheep being given to the donor, according to Akim Abuakwa custom, is that it would be slaughtered and the meat distributed to all members of the family to inform them of the gift. This sheep

[p.1100] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 was never provided by the defendant until the death of the late Kofi Pobi. It is clear therefore that the aseda was not perfected.

The evidence on record shows that the gift was to take effect after the death of Kofi Pobi. All witnesses for the plaintiff said so in their evidence-in-chief, but even though the first defendant witness did not say so in his evidence-in-chief, he admitted on cross-examination, that the gift should take effect after the death of the late Kofi Pobi. If this is the case then in my humble opinion this gift was a conditional gift, which could be recalled or revoked. Dr. Danquah on native customary law says:

“To withdraw or recall a gift is always a matter of controversy. It can hardly be done, but if a father grants his son or daughter a piece of cocoa farm (in our case a building) in anticipation of filial services, and the child deliberately fails to do any service for the father the gift may be taken back.”

In the instant case, there is evidence on record to show that the late Kofi Pobi had complained to his friends and relatives that the children including the defendant had behaved disrespectfully towards him. This piece of evidence was confirmed in exhibit B. In paragraph 3 of that letter written by his solicitor he stated as follows: “. . . some of the children including your goodself have behaved so disrespectfully towards him that he is no more willing to give the house to all the children.”

The defendant said he never got this letter; but the first plaintiff witness who once lived in the house in dispute in his evidence, told the court that the late Kofi Pobi refused to take the aseda offered by the children because of exhibit B which he had caused his solicitor to write to the defendant. The second plaintiff witness also confirmed that the deceased told him that he was revoking the gift because the children did not take him to the hospital when he was ill. The fourth plaintiff witness also stated in his evidence that the deceased mentioned exhibit B to him, and as an executor of exhibit A when he opened the box of the deceased, he saw exhibit B.

These pieces of evidence together with exhibit B convince me that the deceased revoked or recalled the gift and that the defendant received exhibit B. This being the case, on the principle of Dr. Danquah’s authoritative writing, the gift was revoked. And in Owiah v. Biya (1940) D.C. (Land) ‘38-’47, 71, the defendants who were brother and sister, had been given the land in dispute by their father, the plaintiff. They gave him aseda. The evidence showed, as in this case, that the gift was conditional on their looking after him if he became ill, and they were not to have it until after his death. He remained in possession. He later became blind, and the defendants failed to look after him. He offered them back the aseda and when

[p.1101] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 they refused to accept it he brought this action for declaration of title to the land. It was held that the gift was a conditional gift, and a conditional gift could be revoked if the condition was not fulfilled. Moreover this gift was to take effect by way of a legacy on the death of the plaintiff.

That case is on all fours with the instant case. The gift was to take effect by way of legacy on the death of the late Kofi Pobi, and as such he could revoke it as he did; having revoked the gift he could give it to anyone since it was his self-acquired property. In his will, exhibit A, probate of which was granted in due form, the house in dispute was devised to the plaintiff. I hold therefore that house No. W. 114/4, Kibi, became the bona fide property of the plaintiff since probate of the will was granted on 25 September 1980.

One of the reliefs sought by the plaintiff is an account of rents collected by the defendant from all the tenants who occupy the said house. The plaintiff in her evidence stated that there were about eleven tenants in the house. The third plaintiff witness in his evidence gave account of rent recoverable from each tenant in the house as has been stated elsewhere in this judgment. This was denied by the defendant saying that all the tenants in the house were the children of the deceased except two persons who were tenants. However, on cross-examination he admitted that there were eleven tenants in the house but one had left.

The third plaintiff witness on the other hand accounted for the one person who had left by telling the court on cross-examination by the court that the one who had left the house had been replaced by one Attah. This means that there are eleven tenants in the house and are paying rents as stipulated in the evidence adduced by the third plaintiff witness.

This being the case, the rents collected by the defendant from the tenants since the death of the late Kofi Pobi, i.e November 1979 to July 1981 when a receiver and manager was appointed amounted to ¢5,208.

This amount must be paid to the plaintiff since a will speaks from death.

In the final result, I give judgment for the plaintiff as against the defendant as follows: 1. that the defendant gives up possession of house No. W. 114/4 to the plaintiff forthwith; 2. that the defendant pays an amount of ¢5,208 representing rents collected from the house from November 1979 to July 1981; and 3. the injunction placed on the house is hereby revoked and the receiver and manager discharged. He must pay overall rents collected from the house from the date the injunction was [p.1102] of [1982-83] GLR 1094 placed on the house to the plaintiff less his remuneration which is fixed at 10 per cent of the amount collected.

DECISION Costs for the plaintiff in the sum of ¢2,000.

Judgment for the plaintiff M. C. N. – N.

Scroll to Top