SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1981] SLR (HC) 35High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL I)

REPUBLIC vs. JUDICIAL COMMITTEE OF THE CENTRAL REGIONAL HOUSE OF CHIEFS; EX PARTE ADDO [1982-83] GLR 221

3 April 1981 · OSEI-HWERE J · ≈ 8 min read

Cite as[1981] SLR (HC) 35
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAREPUBLIC v JUDICIAL COMMITTEE OF THE CENTRAL REGIONAL HOUSE OF CHIEFS; ex parte ADDO [1982-83] GLR 221 [1981] SLR (HC) 35
APAREPUBLIC v JUDICIAL COMMITTEE OF THE CENTRAL REGIONAL HOUSE OF CHIEFS; ex parte ADDO [1982-83] GLR 221, [1981] SLR (HC) 35 (Ghana).
BluebookREPUBLIC v JUDICIAL COMMITTEE OF THE CENTRAL REGIONAL HOUSE OF CHIEFS; ex parte ADDO [1982-83] GLR 221, [1981] SLR (HC) 35 (Ghana High Ct. 1981).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASE REFERRED TO

Sallah v. Attorney-General, Supreme Court, 20 April 1970, unreported; digested in (1970) C.C. 55.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPLICATION for an order of prohibition to restrain two members of the judicial committee of the Central Regional House of Chiefs from delivering judgment in an appeal which had been argued before them on the ground that the two did not constitute a quorum. The facts are sufficiently stated in the ruling.

COUNSEL

G. K. Acquah for the applicant.

W. N. Adumua-Bossman for the respondents.

JUDGMENT OF OSEI-HWERE J.

By this motion, Mr. G. K. Acquah, counsel for and on behalf of the applicant, prays for an order for the issue of a writ of prohibition against the respondent-judicial committee made up of two members restraining them from sitting and adjudicating on appeal No. 6/77 pending before the said committee. In the accompanying statement the ground for the relief sought is that the judicial committee is made up of two persons and the counsel for the house of chiefs and that this, consequently, infringes section 23 (4) of the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370). In the supporting affidavit, the applicant deposed as follows:

“2. That I am the petitioner-respondent in appeal suit No. 6/77 currently pending at the Central Regional House of Chiefs, Cape Coast and entitled:

Eb. Kwame Addo, Head of Takyina Aboradzi family. v.

Nana Nyan IV and Others.

3. That this appeal was fully argued before the judicial committee of the Central Regional House of

Chiefs composed of three paramount chiefs and the counsel for the house of chiefs.

4. That after the arguments judgment was adjourned indefinitely.

5. Later, hearing notices for the delivery of judgment on 11 July 1980 were served on us. But before that day we received a letter from the counsel of the house postponing the judgment to 25 July 1980. The letter is attached as exhibit A.

[p.223] of [1982-83] GLR 221 6. On 25 July 1980, one of the three panel members of the committee sitting on the case wrote to the house protesting vehemently to the delivery of the judgment on the grounds that he had not been consulted and he had no hand in the delivery of the judgment. He accused his two other colleagues as being biased and consequently stated in the said letter that he had withdrawn as a panel member. This letter is attached s exhibit D.

7. Consequently, it was not possible for judgment to be delivered on that day.

8. That I understand series of behind the scene work were done to bring back this withdrawn member to join his colleagues to deliver judgment, but all to no avail. Consequently, Nana Kyei Baffour II in a letter dated 19 August 1980, herein attached as exhibit B, restated his stand and withdrew from the panel.

9. Despite his withdrawal, and without appointing fresh panel members, the two remaining members are bent on delivering judgment and have caused the registrar of the house to send out fresh notices for judgment to be delivered on 14 November, 1980. I attach the notice as exhibit C.

10. That I am advised and verily believe same to be true that under section 23 (4) and (5) of the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370), they cannot form a quorum to continue judicial proceedings under the Act.

11. That I am further advised that unless they are restrained by an order of this court the two members who do not constitute a quorum are bent on adjudicating on the case.”

The respondent-judicial committee have made no attempt to oppose the motion. However, the defendants-appellants in the appeal before the judicial committee have appeared by their counsel to oppose it. All those statements of fact contained in the applicant’s affidavit as well as in the attached exhibits have not been denied and they must be deemed to have been admitted. In chronological sequence, exhibit A is the letter from the counsel to the respondents which announces to the parties a postponement of the date for judgment from 11 July 1980 to 25 July 1980 because the former date coincided with the Eguadoto of one of the parties. Exhibit D is a letter written on 24 July 1980 by Nana Kyei Baffour II, one of the panel members who sat on appeal, protesting against the intended delivery of the judgment in the appeal the following day. The body of the letter deserves to be quoted in full. It runs:

[p.224] of [1982-83] GLR 221

“Sir, I am one of the panel members in the above-mentioned case. The case is already heard to the end. The counsel informed the panel members by an invitation letter that the panel members were to meet on 7 May 1980 for a discussion on the whole proceedings and judgment given on 11 June 1980.

Members met on 7 May 1980 when the counsel was absent. No fresh invitation letter has been served on the panel members since then.

To my uttermost surprise I learned from the counsel that judgment is going to be given on 24 July 1980 without my participation in the discussion on that particular judgment. The counsel tells me today that he has had discussions on the case with Nana Nkusukum, the chairman and Nana Enyan Abaasa so judgment can be given on the aforementioned date.

I am writing this letter to object to whatever decision they have taken without me. Secondly, I have the confidence that the counsel and the other two panel members have taken this decision on a biased motive.

Therefore, I am suggesting to the registrar to suspend whatever judgment to be given tomorrow 25 July 1980, then set up a fresh committee to go into the above case afresh, because I feel there is a bad motive behind why I was left out in the discussion before judgment.

Thank you.

Yours faithfully, (Sgd.) Nana Kyei Baffour II.”

Exhibit D was addressed to the registrar of the Central Regional House of Chiefs and copied to the president of the house of chiefs, the plaintiff-respondent and the first defendant-appellant. In exhibit B which was written on 19 August 1980, Nana Kyei Baffour II maintained his stand that he had withdrawn as a panel member and that his conscience did not permit him to join his colleagues on the case. Exhibit C is the hearing notice issued on 3 November 1980 on the parties to inform them that judgment would be delivered on 14 November 1980.

It is plain from exhibit D that when counsel for the house of chiefs issued the hearing notice in exhibit A, the panel members had not met in conference with counsel to deliberate on their judgment. As is stated in exhibit D, the members met on 7 May 1980 when counsel was absent and that no fresh invitation letter had been served on the panel members since then. The inference I am invited to draw that the panel members formulated the outlines of their judgment is invalid. In

[p.225] of [1982-83] GLR 221 my view, the argument of opposing counsel on what must have taken place on 7 May 1980 is purely speculative. No affidavit has been filed to clear the air. Indeed, the absence of any indication that the panel members had by themselves agreed on a date to meet their counsel suggests to me that they conducted no business on that day. How the judicial committee got a judgment ready to be delivered on 25 July (as per exhibit B) is anybody’s guess.

It is no wonder that Nana Kyei Baffour II was “surprised to the uttermost” to learn that a judgment was going to be delivered. I really do not know the practice at the regional house of chiefs before their judicial committee comes to deliver their judgment. I do not know whether, awed by the presence of legal advocates in their forum, they abandon their judicial function in arriving at a decision to their counsel who will write the judgment and then call on the panel members to ratify it or whether they deliberate and come to their own decision and derive their only assistance from their counsel on the law.

The former, if practised, stands to condemnation. The fact remains that Nana Kyei Baffour II complains that he has not taken part in any deliberation to arrive at a decision which in the obvious wisdom of section 24 (4) of Act 370, makes three heads better than two. Insofar as all the three panel members did not deliberate beforehand on a decision, any production of a judgment cannot be their act and, therefore, an infringement of section 23 (4) of Act 370.

Counsel for the applicant has invited the court to distinguish the incident which led Siriboe J.A., a member of the full court, to withdraw at the closing stage in the celebrated case of Sallah v. Attorney-General, Supreme Court, Accra, 20 April 1970, unreported; digested in (1970) C.C. 55. In that case, Siriboe J.A. declined an invitation to sit with his brothers of the full bench to deliver judgment. From the statement appended to the judgment by the president of the full bench, it is disclosed that he took part in the hearing of the case to its conclusion and also in the judgment conference held on Tuesday, 24 March 1970 between 9.35 a.m. and 12.25 p.m. when a decision was reached. He dissented from the decision of the majority and agreed to articulate his dissent in a judgment to be delivered on 13 April 1970. The president of the court observed that as Siriboe J.A. said he had withdrawn they took that to mean that the reason for his dissent was not ready and if it was, it would be made part of the official record. The result assumed by this withdrawal of a member is quite different from the result which I have stated, where Nana Kyei Baffour II took no part in any conference.

I have been invited by counsel for the defendants-appellants in the appeal before the judicial committee, to hold that the purported withdrawal of Nana Kyei Baffour II is null and void. Whether or not

[p.226] of [1982-83] GLR 221 his withdrawal is invalid can, in my view, only be determined by inquiring into the statute and regulations which govern his appointment as a member of the panel constituting the judicial committee. Both Act 370 and the regulations made thereunder are silent on this matter and I cannot see any reason, except for inconvenience, why a panel member cannot feel free to withdraw upon the dictates of his own conscience. The applicant has fully driven home his grounds for the application and I order that until the panel is properly constituted, prohibition should lie as prayed in the motion, and I so order its issuance with ¢200 costs against the defendants-appellants, the opposers.

DECISION

Application granted.

M. C. N. -N.

Scroll to Top