SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1980] SLR (HC) 31High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1981

INGOS CONSTRUCTION LTD. vs. BLACKWOOD HODGE (GHANA) LTD. [1981] GLR 347

21 February 1980 · SARKODEE J · ≈ 4 min read

Cite as[1980] SLR (HC) 31
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAINGOS CONSTRUCTION LTD. v BLACKWOOD HODGE (GHANA) LTD. [1981] GLR 347 [1980] SLR (HC) 31
APAINGOS CONSTRUCTION LTD. v BLACKWOOD HODGE (GHANA) LTD. [1981] GLR 347, [1980] SLR (HC) 31 (Ghana).
BluebookINGOS CONSTRUCTION LTD. v BLACKWOOD HODGE (GHANA) LTD. [1981] GLR 347, [1980] SLR (HC) 31 (Ghana High Ct. 1980).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPLICATION for transfer of suit from the High Court, Sekondi, to the High Court, Accra. The facts are sufficiently stated in the ruling.

COUNSEL

Bentsi-Enchil for the plaintiff-respondents.

S. Amarteifio for the defendant-applicants.

JUDGMENT OF SARKODEE J.

By this motion the defendants are asking this court for an order to transfer this case to the High Court, Accra, where the defendants reside or carry on business and to be heard there. The plaintiffs resist the application and say that by article 124 of the Constitution, 1979, there is only one High Court of Justice. Also that in view of the facts deposed to in the affidavit, the High Court, Sekondi, is the most convenient venue for the trial.

The substantive suit itself is a sequel to an action instituted in Sekondi against the defendants in the present suit by one Sarah Arkhurst, who was a business partner of Ingos Construction Ltd., the plaintiffs in the present suit. In the Salah Arkhurst case the plaintiff asked for specific performance of a contract for the purchase of a quarry machine and damages, among other reliefs. It came out at the trial of that suit that cheques issued by Ingos Construction Ltd. for the payment of the machine were returned because of statements alleged to have been made by the bankers of Ingos Construction Ltd., which bank was in Takoradi. It was as a result of that statement that the present plaintiffs have instituted this action for libel.

The defendants are a limited liability company registered in Accra where they carry on business. They contend therefore that in accordance with the High Court (Civil Procedure) (Amendment) Rules, 1977 (L.I. 1107), the Greater Accra Region and not the Western Region is the proper region in which the action should have been brought. Quite apart from L.I. 1107, r. 6 they say, they believe that Accra is the most convenient venue for the trial of the action.

Upon a closer look at L.I. 1107 as a whole and, rule 8 thereof in particular and having regard to article 124 of the Constitution, 1979, which provides that there is only one High Court of Justice, it seems to me that the court before which an application is made for transfer of a suit instituted in a region other than that specified by rule 1 (6) of L.I. 1107 has a discretion in the matter. The court ought to look at all the circumstances and decide whether or not to order a transfer of the suit. It seems to me every case must turn on its own peculiar facts but the test to be applied in each particular case,

[p.349] of [1981] GLR 347

where the defendant applies that the matter be transferred is whether the defendant would suffer some injustice if the action was heard in the region where he does not reside or carry on business. The defendant must be able to prove either that expenses or the difficulties of trial in that region would be so great that injustice would be done in the sense that it would be difficult or practically impossible for the litigant who is applying for the transfer to have justice in that region.

The libel complained of was published in Takoradi, in the Western Region. The bank where the plaintiffs have an account is at Takoradi. The cheques which gave rise to the statement complained of was issued on a Takoradi bank, the manager of the bank is resident at Takoradi and all relevant documents of the bank are kept in Takoradi. Against these, are the defendants who are registered in Accra and carry on business there. They would not have to move staff or documents to the Western Region for the trial. On the other hand, it is difficult to conceive anything more harassing for the bank than to have their officials dragged up to Accra for a lengthy trial, when together with their officials they have to take to Accra and keep away from their business, witnesses, books, papers and documents. The only apparent hardship to which the defendant can point to is that their representative and witnesses will have to travel to Sekondi if the application is refused. If they were able to travel to Sekondi to defend the Sarah Arkhurst case, the defendants ought not to find it any greater hardship to come to the Western Region to defend the present action.

In my view, the balance of hardship is on the side of the plaintiffs. I do not think the defendants would suffer any injustice in coming to the Western Region to defend this action; on the contrary to transfer it to Accra would result in injustice to the plaintiffs. In the circumstances the application is refused.

DECISION

Application for transfer refused.

S. O. K. O.

Scroll to Top