SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1978] SLR (CA) 22Court of Appeal - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1979

REPUBLIC vs. ANLO TRADITIONAL COUNCIL; EX PARTE HOR II [1979] GLR 234

12 May 1978 · KINGSLEY-NYINAH JA · ≈ 22 min read

Cite as[1978] SLR (CA) 22
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAREPUBLIC v ANLO TRADITIONAL COUNCIL; ex parte HOR II [1979] GLR 234 [1978] SLR (CA) 22
APAREPUBLIC v ANLO TRADITIONAL COUNCIL; ex parte HOR II [1979] GLR 234, [1978] SLR (CA) 22 (Ghana).
BluebookREPUBLIC v ANLO TRADITIONAL COUNCIL; ex parte HOR II [1979] GLR 234, [1978] SLR (CA) 22 (Ghana Ct. App. 1978).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASES REFERRED TO

(1) Khoury v. Richter, High Court, 8 December 1958, unreported,

(2) Majolagbe v. Larbi [1959] G.L.R. 190.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPEAL from a judgment of Andoh J. wherein he granted an order of prohibition to prevent the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council from determining a constitutional matter to which the respondent was a party. The facts are fully set out in the judgment of Jiagge J.A.

COUNSEL

Dr. Obed Asamoah (Nutsugah with him) for the appellants.

B. J. da Rocha (Tsegah with him) for the respondents.

JUDGMENT JIAGGE J.A.

By an originating summons issued at the instance of Michael Fini and two others against Togbe Hor II, Fiaga of Agbosome and two others, the plaintiffs claimed before the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council that by custom and tradition their family was the “proper” one to select and install the “dufia” of Adafienu; that the said family nominated one Jacob Komlavi Tormety as the successor in title of the late Chief Dovo II of Adafienu, that the nomination was subsequently approved by the three wing chiefs of Somey and that the customary

[p.236] of [1979] GLR 234 installation fees were also paid. However, the first defendant had for six years “persistently conspired with the other defendants to make the installation impossible to be performed.”

The defendants in their statement of defence averred that “Togbe Tsri Dapensu II, the senior stool father and dufia of Adafienu and his elders are by custom and tradition the proper persons to select and install the divisional chief or dufia of Adafienu” and further that “the late Togbe Dovo II was a “war chief’ or “awafia” and not the divisional chief of Adafienu. The defendants averred that the “plaintiffs made abortive attempts to coerce them to install Jacob Komiavi Tormety as the divisional chief of Adafienu contrary to custom and tradition.” The first defendant, Togbe Hor II, also averred that “he is the paramount chief of the Somey people and that the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council has no jurisdiction over him” and further that the matter did not arise within the area of the Anlo Traditional Council.

In an ex parte application for leave to issue an order for prohibition, counsel on behalf of Togbe Hor II contended that the Anlo Traditional Council had no jurisdiction over the matter in question and that the proper forum was the Volta Regional House of Chiefs because his client was a paramount chief.

The court in granting leave observed, “The most controversial issue . . . is whether he (the applicant) is a paramount chief or divisional chief. If the applicant is a paramount chief, then the contention by him may be sustained; if not the application may fail.” The court after directing service on the respondents to the motion ordered a stay of the proceedings before the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council until disposition of this application.”

In an affidavit in opposition sworn to by Francis Awuku, the registrar of the Anlo Traditional Council on behalf of the said council, he averred:

“That the Anlo Traditional Area over which the Anlo Traditional Council has jurisdiction in constitutional matters includes Somey… That except for a brief period of about four years (1962-66) . . . Somey has always been subject to the jurisdiction of the Anlo Traditional Council.”

And finally, “That the applicant is not a paramount chief within the meaning of the laws of chieftaincy in this country.”

The respondents to the motion, Michael Fini and some two others, also filed an affidavit in opposition stating, inter alia, that there were only fourteen traditional areas in the Volta Region and that Somey was not one of them and “That from time immemorial the Fiaga of Agbosome . . . has always been subject to the jurisdiction of the Anlo Traditional Area; that the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council is the proper authority to adjudicate in chieftaincy disputes within the Anlo Traditional Area.”

The learned trial judge in granting the order for prohibition after hearing the argument of counsel on either side declared in his judgment

[p.237] of [1979] GLR 234

(see Republic v. Anlo Traditional Council; Ex parte Hor II [1978] G. L.R. 105 at p. 111):

“I am not sure of the soundness of the conclusions I have reached and I think the ruling needs a further review elsewhere.

Until the appropriate action is taken to cancel or withdraw or quash the Local Government Bulletin No. 25 of 6 June 1975 or until publication of a new Local Government Bulletin that the applicant is a fiaga—a divisional chief of the Anlo Traditional Council, or a fia, I think he is entitled to masquerade as a Fiaga of Somey Traditional Area. I cannot conduct any inquiry as to the actual status of the applicant beyond looking at the Local Government Bulletin aforementioned. Thereunder it appears that the applicant is recognised by the government, probably by mistake, as a paramount chief or Fiaga of Somey Traditional Area.”

The main grounds of appeal argued before this court were:

“(1) The learned trial judge erred in regarding the Local Government Bulletin No. 25 of 6 June 1975 as sufficient to establish the status of the applicant as a paramount chief.

Additional grounds of appeal:

(2) The learned trial judge erred in holding that by virtue of the Local Government Bulletin No. 25 of 6 June 1975 no further inquiry as to the actual status of the applicant was called for and thereby exercised his discretion wrongly in favour of the applicant.

(3) The learned trial judge erred in exercising his discretion in the applicant’s favour inasmuch as the issue before the Anlo Traditional Council was within the jurisdiction of a traditional council.

(4) The learned trial judge erred in exercising his discretion in the applicant’s favour inasmuch as there were other defendants over whom the Anlo Traditional Council had jurisdiction.

(5) The learned trial judge erred in holding that even if the applicant were a divisional chief he would not be subject to the jurisdiction of the Anlo Traditional Council once he had raised objection to the exercise by the traditional council of jurisdiction over him.”

The High Court, before the exercise of its powers of supervision over the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council, must be satisfied that there is prima facie evidence of the existence of the mischief it has been called upon to prohibit. Section 15 of the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370), provides:

“15. (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act and to any appeal therefrom, a Traditional Council shall have exclusive jurisdiction to bear and determine any cause or matter affecting chieftaincy which arises within its area, not being one to which the Asantehene or a Paramount Chief is a party.”

[p.238] of [1979] GLR 234

The judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council therefore would have no jurisdiction if (1) Togbe Hor II (who was a party) was a paramount chief; (2) Adafienu where the cause or matter affecting chieftaincy arose was not within the territorial limits of the Anlo Traditional Council.

On the status of Togbe Hor II, the evidence before the court was the information contained in Local Government Bulletin No. 25 of Friday, 6 June 1975. The trial judge observed in his judgment at p. 1071, “I must say in passing that I do not think that the information contained in the bulletin in is conclusive.” However, he in fact gave effect to the said information in the Local Government Bulletin No. 25 of 6 June as conclusive evidence that the first respondent, Togbe Hor II, was a paramount chief of the Somey Traditional Area.

The Local Government Bulletin No 25 of 6 June 1975 was itself couched in very cautious language. It provides:

“NOTICE OF CHANGES AFFECTING THE STATUS OF CERTAIN CHIEFS— The public are hereby informed that the following changes in the status of the chiefs mentioned in the Schedule hereto have been notified to the Government and the Government hereby takes cognisance of the changes:— . . . Enstoolment—8-4-71—Sampson Kwabla—Fiaga of Somey—Togbe Hor II—Agbosome—Somey Traditional Area.”

This notification was made in accordance with section 51 (1)-(2) of Act 370 which provides that:

“51. (1) All enstoolments, destoolments, abdications and deaths of Chiefs in any Region as well as all such other changes in the status of Chiefs as maybe prescribed by regulations made under section 62 of this Act shall as soon as practicable after their occurrence, be reported in writing to the Minister by the Regional House of Chiefs of the Region through the National House of Chiefs.

(2) Subject to sections 48 of this Act, the Minister shall upon receipt of any such report cause its contents to be published in the Local Government Bulletin for the information of the general public.

The Minister had the duty to publish the information received by him from the regional house of chiefs through the National House of Chiefs. The Minister had no power to pronounce on its validity, he had power merely to take “cognisance of the changes.” However, the publication, being an official Act, must be given due consideration.

It is significant to note, however, that although the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370), replaced and repealed the Chieftaincy Act, 1961 (Act 81), it did not preserve all the powers exercised by the Minister under Act 81.

For instance Act 81, s. 1 provided:

“1. (1) A Chief is an individual who— (a) has been nominated, elected and installed as a Chief in accordance with customary law, and (b) is recognized as a Chief by the Minister . . .”

[p.239] of [1979] GLR 234

But Act 370 provides in section 48 as follows:

“48 (1) A Chief is an individual who has, in accordance with customary law, been nominated, elected, and installed as a Chief or as the case may be appointed and installed as such and whose name for the time being appears as a Chief on the National Register of Chiefs:

Provided that no person shall be deemed to be a Chief for the purposes of the exercise by him of any function under this Act of under any other enactment, unless he has been recognised as such by the Minister by notice published in the Local Government Bulletin.”

Under Act 81 to be a chief, the individual must not only have been nominated, elected and installed as a chief but must also have been recognised as a chief by the Minister. The provision for recognition as Chief by the Minister was repealed by and replaced in Act 370, s. 48(1) by the provisions that the name of the individual must appear as a chief on the National Register of Chiefs. Another example of the limitations imposed under Act 370 on exercise of powers conferred on the Minister was in relation to the creation of traditional councils.

Act 81, s. 12 (1)-(2) provided:

“12. (1) Where immediately before the commencement of this Act a State Council was in existence under an enactment repealed by this Act for an area which substantially corresponds to a traditional area, that Council shall, subject to section 14 of this Act, be the Traditional Council for the area, and shall no longer be known as a State Council.

(2) Where the preceding subsection does not apply in relation to one or more traditional areas, the Minister may constitute a Council to be the Traditional Council for that area, or those areas jointly, as the case may be.

No such power exists under Act 370. Section 12 of Act 370 on traditional councils provides:

“12. (1) There shall be a Traditional Council for each tradition area and the Traditional Councils in existence immediately before the commencement of this Act shall continue in existence for the traditional areas in respect of which they existed immediately before the said commencement.

(2) The name of every Traditional Council shall be shown in the National Register of Chiefs maintained under section 50 of this Act.”

The traditional areas in existence before the commencement of Act 370 were defined in Act 81, s. 11 which provided.

“11. A traditional area is the area within which a Paramount Chief or, in the case of the Kumasi traditional area, the Asantehene exercises jurisdiction and which is specified in the Chiefs List as a traditional area, and such areas shall no longer be known as States.”

[p.240] of [1979] GLR 234

In exercise of his powers under Act 81, the Minister in 1962 by elevating divisional stools to paramount stools created a number of new traditional areas and councils, and recognised new chiefs and these were published in the Local Government Bulletin No. 48 of 30 November 1962. The Somey stool was one of those elevated from a divisional to a paramount stool and the Somey Traditional Area was created.

The position before 1962 was as indicated in State Councils (Colony and Southern Togoland) Ordinance (No. 8 of 1952), Schedule III. The states in the Trans-Volta Region were shown in Schedule III and the states existing in Togoland were shown in Schedule II. The Somey Traditional Area did not exist, only two states existed in the Trans-Volta Region which was part of the Gold Coast and distinct from Togoland which was then a trust territory. The two states of the Trans-Volta Region were Anlo and Peki. The Somey Traditional Area came into existence for the first time in 1962 and the Somey stool was elevated to paramount stool by the Minister in the exercise of his powers under Act 81, s. 12 (2) as already stated in this judgment.

Later in 1966 the Chieftaincy (Amendment) Decree, 1966 (N.L.C.D. 112), was promulgated and paragraphs 1 (1) and 2 provided that:

“1. (1) Chiefs at any time occupying the stools specified in the First Schedule to this Decree being stools the chiefs of which were contrary to customary law at various times before the commencement of this Decree elevated or treated as elevated to the status of Paramount Chiefs by the Government of Kwame Nkrumah, shall, notwithstanding anything to the contrary, be deemed to have reverted to the status enjoyed respectively by chiefs of those stools immediately before the said elevation or as the case may be, immediately before they began to be treated as so elevated and accordingly, any Traditional Council existing in the Traditional area of any such chief immediately before the commencement of this Decree is hereby dissolved and also the Chiefs List in existence immediately before the commencement of this Decree shall be deemed to be amended accordingly.”

“2. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, where immediately before the elevation of any chief referred to in paragraph 1 of this Decree or as the case may be where before any such chief began to be treated as elevated, that chief was, or would have been within jurisdiction of or subject to the authority of any Traditional Council (howsoever then described) or where immediately before any such time there existed or would have existed a relationship between the chief and any other chief whereby the first mentioned chief owed allegiance to that other chief then, on the commencement of this Decree the first mentioned chief shall be deemed to have come within the jurisdiction of or to have become subject to the authority of the said Traditional Council or as the case may be, the said relationship shall be deemed to have been restored.”

[p.241] of [1979] GLR 234

Somey was one of the stools affected by N.L.C.D. 112, paras. 1 and 2 and the occupant of the Somey stool reverted to his former status and allegiance and the Somey Traditional Area was accordingly dissolved. The former status and allegiance of the chief of Somey were as shown in the Gold Coast Chief’s List 1941 which was accepted in evidence at the hearing in the lower court as exhibit I. In this list Somey appears as a division of Anlo State and the chief of Agbosome was described as Fia Adama II. He was the immediate predecessor in title of Togbe Hor II, the first respondent herein. No legal instrument has since elevated the occupant of the Somey stool to a paramount chief nor has there been any instrument since creating a Somey Traditional Area.

N.L.C.D. 112 was repealed by section 67 of the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370). But the Chieftaincy (Status of Chiefs) Decree, 1972 (N.R.C.D. 99), provides:

“For the avoidance of doubts it is hereby declared that the repeal by section 67 of the Chieftaincy Act, 1971 (Act 370) of the Decrees specified in the Schedule to this Decree shall not be deemed to have affected the status of any chief, stool or skin as it existed immediately before the repeal.”

N.L.C.D. 112 was the first of the Decrees mentioned in the Schedule to N.R.C.D. 99.

The position immediately before the repeal of N.L.C.D. 112 by Act 370 on 17 September 1971, was that the status of the occupant of the Somey stool was that a of a divisional chief. If at the time his enstoolment on 8 April 1971 there was any doubt as to the effect of N.L.C.D. 112 on the status of Togbe Hor II, N.R.C.D. 99 removed any such doubt that might have existed on the issue. Similarly no legal instrument exists today to support the claim that there is a Somey Traditional Area.

The Chieftaincy (Membership of Regional Houses of Chiefs) Instrument, 1974 (L.I. 991), firmly placed the occupant of the Somey stool among “fiawo”—chiefs—and not “fiaga”— paramount chiefs. The paramount chief of the Anlo Traditional Area of which Somey is a division is described as “Awoamefia of Anlo.” Recently in 1977 by the Chieftaincy (Establishment of Traditional Councils) Instrument, 1977 (L.I. 1131), new traditional councils were created in the Volta Region but “Somey” definitely was not one of them.

A trial court has the duty to take judicial notice of prevailing legislation and legislative instruments. If the trial judge had given due consideration to the law as it exists, he would not have landed himself in the confusion that made him exclaim at p. 110:

“I am stunned to find that no traditional council is shown to exist with Somey Traditional Area. It seems to me that by virtue of the Chieftaincy (Amendment) Decree, 1966 (N.L.C.D. 112), now repealed Somey is still under the Anlo Traditional Council. At the same time it is arguable that it is an independent traditional area but without a traditional council.”

[p.242] of [1979] GLR 234

There is nothing arguable about the so-called independent Somey Traditional Area which can only exist when it is created by a legal instrument. There is no such instrument and the Local Government Bulletin No.25 of Friday 6 June 1975 on which the trial judge based the gravamen of his decision cannot take the place, of an enabling Act. It cannot under the circumstances even serve as a prima facie evidence that Togbe Hor II is a chief, because Act 370, s. 50 (8)-(9) make provisions for what should be prima facie evidence that an individual is a chief: failure to produce a certified true copy of the relevant contents of the national register of chiefs in accordance with section 50 of Act 370 was failure to produce the necessary prima facie evidence on which the trial court could act. The learned trial judge misdirected himself when he accepted that Togbe Hor II was the paramount chief of an independent traditional area namely, Somey Traditional Area, and therefore the Anlo Traditional Council is ousted from hearing or determining the matter or cause affecting him in his capacity as a paramount chief. Section 48 (1) of the Chieftaincy Act 1971 (Act 370), provides the legal answer to the question, “Who is a chief ?” It provides:

“48. (1) A Chief is an individual who has, in accordance with customary law, been nominated, elected and installed as a Chief or as the case may be appointed and installed as such and whose name for the time being appears as a Chief on the National Register of Chiefs:

Provided that no person shall be deemed to be a Chief for the purposes of the exercise by him of any function under this Act or under any other enactment, unless he has been recognised as such by the Minister by notice published in the Local Government Bulletin.

(2) Subject to the foregoing subsection (1) the name of any person who has been installed as a Chief shall be entered by the National House of Chiefs in the National Register of Chiefs not later than one month from the date of the receipt of the notification of such installation.”

Section 49 of Act 370 gives the various categories of chiefs, i.e. paramount chiefs, divisional chiefs, etc., etc. Section 66 of the same Act provides the legal interpretation of the words paramount chiefs, divisional chiefs and so on.

Clearly any individual who claims to be a chief, in addition to being nominated, elected and installed as a chief in accordance with customary law, must also have his name recorded as chief on the National Register of Chiefs: see section 48 (1). Section 50 (1) of Act 370 provides that, “The National House of Chiefs shall maintain a register to be known as ‘the National Register of Chiefs’. . .” Subsections (2)-(7) set out detailed provisions on how such a register is to be maintained. Sub-section (8) provides, “The contents of the Register shall be prima facie evidence of the existence of any facts or particulars stated therein.” Subsection (9) provides:

[p.243] of [1979] GLR 234

“(9) In any legal proceedings the contents of the Register or any part thereof maybe proved by a copy thereof duly certified under the hand of the Registrar to the National House of Chiefs or any public officer authorised by him in writing to be a true copy of the contents or of that part.”

Any individual claiming to be a chief in any legal proceedings therefore must produce a certified true copy of the relevant section of the register showing his status as a chief. This in accordance with section 50 (8) is prima facie evidence that he is a chief. The publication in the Local Government Bulletin No.25 of Friday 6 June 1975, did not in any way relieve the first respondent of this burden of proof.

As a matter of practice, great caution accompanies the exercise of discretionary powers under prerogative orders. The prerogative has been defined as “The residue of discretionary or arbitrary authority which at any given time, is legally left in the hands of the Crown (i.e. State). As prohibition issues as of right only where the defect of jurisdiction is clear, i.e. where it is apparent on the face of the proceedings that there was absence or excess of jurisdiction and also where there was an obvious departure from the rules of natural justice. However, where the defect is not clear and there is some doubt either in fact or in law whether or not the inferior tribunal is exceeding its jurisdiction or is acting without jurisdiction, the court has a discretion and may decline to interpose unless the request for prohibition is well founded.

In this case the question upon which the jurisdiction of the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Area depends is one of fact, i.e. whether or not the first respondent is a paramount chief and whether or not Somey is within the Anlo Traditional Area.

The High Court itself has no jurisdiction to delve into any chieftaincy cause or matter. However, in the exercise of his discretion in favour of the first respondent, the trial judge had a duty to ensure that there was prima facie evidence that the first respondent was a chief in accordance with the provisions of sections 48 (1) and 50 (8)-(9) of Act 370. There was no such prima facie evidence before the court and the trial judge erred in exercising his discretion in favour of the respondents as the mischief to be prohibited did not in fact exist.

In view of the reasons stated, this appeal is allowed. The order for prohibition issued against the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council is set aside, as the application for prohibition was not well founded.

JUDGMENT OF KINGSLEY-NYINAH J.A.

I agree.

JUDGMENT OF EDUSEI J.A.

I have read the judgment of the president of the court and am in agreement with the conclusion reached. I wish, however, to add a few words of my own in further elucidation of the two main issues which, in my judgment, emerged in the course of arguments of the application before the trial court.

[p.244] of [1979] GLR 234

In order for the first respondent (hereinafter referred to as the applicant) to succeed, and the whole case centred around him, it was encumbent on him to show either (a) he is the paramount chief (fiaga) of Agbosome or (b) the issue for determination is properly justiciable by the Somey Traditional Council, if there is such a council, and not by the Anlo Traditional Council.

It is quite clear that since the applicant was seeking the remedy of order of prohibition against the judicial committee of the Anlo Traditional Council the burden was on him to show that he is the fiaga of Agbosome. The names of persons who have been installed as chiefs of various classes including paramount chiefs are recorded in the National Register of Chiefs by the National House of Chiefs: see Act 370, s.48 (2). Again section 50 (8) of Act 370 provides: “The contents of the Register shall be prima facie evidence of the existence of any facts or particulars stated therein.” Section 50 (9) also states:

“(9) In any legal proceedings the contents of the Register or any part thereof may be proved by a copy thereof duly certified under the hand of the Registrar to the National House of Chiefs or any public office authorized by him in writing to be a true copy of the contents or of that part.”

The register referred to in these two subsections is the National Register of Chiefs: see Act 370, s. 50 (1).The applicant in order to establish that he is a fiaga or paramount chief of Agbosome had the simple duty of procuring and attaching to his application a certified true copy of the portion of the national register in which his name appears as paramount chief of Agbosome. This would have provided him with a prima facie evidence at least of his status and the appellants, if they so wished, could rebut this by some sort of superior evidence. But this statutory proof was not forthcoming from the applicant. The mere averment of the fact of his status as paramount chief of Agbosome in his affidavit supporting his application is not, in the circumstances, sufficient. It is tantamount to his mountings the witness-box and repeating on oath that he is a paramount chief, and this is no proof of that all-important fact of his paramountcy and the classical words of Ollennu J. in Khoury v. Richter, High Court, 8 December 1958, unreported which are referred to in the oft-cited case of Majolagbe v. Larbi [1959] G.L.R. 190 at p. 192 are apposite in this connection. The words are:

“Proof in law is the establishment of facts by proper legal means. Where a party makes an averment capable of proof in some positive way e.g. by producing documents, description of things, reference to other facts, instances, or circumstances, and his averment is denied, he does not prove it by merely going into the witness box and repeating that averment on oath, or having it repeated on oath by his witness. He proves it by producing other evidence of facts and circumstances, from which the Court can be satisfied that what he avers is true.”

[p.245] of [1979] GLR 234

In this case the applicant, when his status as paramount chief was denied by the registrar of the Anlo Traditional Council in an opposing affidavit, could have established the fact of his status as a paramount chief by the production of a certified copy of the contents of the national register showing that he is the paramount chief of Agbosome. This he did not do, and Act 370 directs such matters to be proved in this way.

Apart from the statutory mode of proof he did not offer any other satisfactory evidence in proof of his status as a paramount chief. He plainly failed, therefore, to discharge the onus that rested on him.

The second issue is whether the matter arises within the area of the Anlo Traditional Council or not. With regard to this matter the main judgment of the president of the court has dealt with it at great length and I would only add that if there was a Somey Traditional Council and the matter could be determined before it and not before the Anlo Traditional Council, it was capable of proof in the same way as a person can prove that he is a chief—i.e. by the production of a certified copy of the contents of the national register since section 12 (2) of Act 370 provides that, “The name of every Traditional Council shall be shown in the National Register of Chiefs maintained under section 50 of this Act,” and see also section 50(8) of Act 370 as regard the mode of proof. This also the applicant failed to do, and a statutory means of proof cannot be flouted with impunity.

It is abundantly clear that the applicant who sought the remedy of order of prohibition did not discharge the burden of proof in the manner prescribed by statute not by any other admissible evidence. The trial judge therefore erred in granting the application. It is no less surprising that the trial judge himself expressed doubt about his ruling when he opined thus at p. 111: I am not sure of the soundness of the conclusions I have reached and I think the ruling needs a further review elsewhere.” Perhaps I can add that the doubt of the trial judge has amply been justified by this court in reversing his ruling.

Finally, I wish to recommend to the Anlo Traditional Council that its judicial committee should be composed of members of the same status as the applicant, a divisional chief, when the latter appears before it, and this, in my view, will do away with any sense of injustice that the applicant may habour in his mind, for a sense of injustice is a grievous thing.

DECISION

Appeal allowed.

D. R. K. S.

Scroll to Top