BRIGHT vs. GRAPHIC CORPORATION [1980] GLR 833
15 January 1980 · OSEI-HWERE J · ≈ 13 min read
[1980] SLR (HC) 5Other citation styles and permanent link
SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.
CASES REFERRED TO
(1) Capital Finance Co., Ltd. v. Bray [1964] 1 W.L.R. 323; [1964] 1 All E.R. 603; 108 S.J. 95, C.A.
(2) Clements v. Flight (1846) 16 M. & W. 42; 16 L.J.Ex. 11; 8 L.T. (O.S.) 166; 4 Dow. & L. 261; I New Pract. Cas. 567.
(3) Travers (Joseph) & Sons, Ltd. v. Cooper [1915] 1 K.B. 73; 83 L.J.K.B. 1787; 111 L.T. 1088; 30 T.L.R. 703; 12 Asp.M.L.C. 561; 20 Com.Cas. 44, C.A.
(4) Morison, Pollexfen & Blair v. Walton, 10 May 1909, unreported, H.L.
(5) Howard v. Harris (1884) 1 Cab. & El. 253.
[p.835] of [1980] GLR 833
(6) General and Finance Facilities, Ltd. v. Cooks Cars (Romford) Ltd. [1963] 2 All E.R. 314; [1963] 1 W.L.R. 644; 107 S.J. 294, C.A.
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS
ACTION for the return of printing blocks or for the recovery of their value. The facts are fully set out in the judgment.
COUNSEL
The plaintiff in person.
E. M. Amponsah-Dadzie for the defendants.
JUDGMENT OF OSEI-HWERE J.
The plaintiff’s claim against the defendants is for “a return of two printing blocks on swollen shoot or their value of ¢30,000.” In his amended statement of claim the plaintiff pleaded the following pertinent matters among others:
“(1) The plaintiff is a physiotherapist and naturopathic physician and doctor of botanic medicine, practising in Cape Coast, and the defendants, a daily newspaper corporation doing business all over the country and in Cape Coast, with headquarters in Accra.
(2) On 28 February 1972, the plaintiff despatched a block of healthy and unhealthy cocoa plants on swollen shoot, with an article on swollen shoot for publication for the public to know we have a man here to do the job, instead of asking from abroad; though not advert as it may mean.
(3) The defendant-corporation refused or failed to do the publication, and so the plaintiff called for the return of the two blocks, and despite repeated demands the blocks have not been returned to the plaintiff.
(4) On 7 October 1976, the editor in the person of Mr. I. K. Nkrumah wrote to say that the blocks had been misplaced and that plaintiff should send the art-work of the swollen shoot to enable them to make new blocks for replacement.”
From the evidence of the plaintiff it was actually a two-in-one block on swollen shoot that he despatched together with his article for publication, and he tendered in evidence as exhibit A the print impression of the blocks. Before the editor of the defendants-corporation came to write the letter mentioned in paragraph (4) of the statement of claim, the plaintiff had written to the then Head of State, General I. K. Acheampong, complaining about the defendants’ attitude of nonchalance towards the article he had sent for publication and also about their failure to return his blocks. His copy of the letter to the then Head of State is exhibit C and the letter from the
[p.836] of [1980] GLR 833 editor, Mr. I. K. Nkrumah, exhibit D. This letter from the editor is worthy to be quoted in full and it ran:
“Dear Sir, SWOLLEN SHOOT BLOCK HEALTHY AND UNHEALTHY COCOA TREE We refer to your letter of 21 July 1976 addressed to the office of the Supreme Military Council on the above-mentioned subject-matter and regret to inform you that the two printing blocks on swollen shoot referred to have been misplaced.
We are therefore asking you to send us copy of the art-work of the swollen shoot to enable us make new blocks to replace the missing ones.
You will appreciate the fact that the Editor of the Graphic who might have received your letter in 1972 is no longer on the staff of the corporation. Your letter to the office of the S.M.C. was therefore news to the present Editor since there is nothing on file about your swollen shoot blocks.
Hoping to hear from you at your earliest convenience.
Yours faithfully (Sgd.) I. K. Nkrumah Editor, Graphic.”
Following this letter, the plaintiff said that he sent a copy of exhibit A to the defendants from which they could make the blocks in replacement. The defendants subsequently published in their newspaper part of the article he sent to them and the pictures similar to the art-work in exhibit A also appeared with the publication. The Daily Graphic of Friday 6 May 1977 in which the publication appeared was tendered as exhibit E. When he saw the pictures in exhibit E he thought that they had produced the correct block and so he wrote to the defendants and later followed up to collect the blocks. The defendants gave him a block but, metaphorically speaking, as he is not that bird who could easily be caught with chaff, he demanded that they strike on paper a specimen of the pictures that the block produces. They complied and what came out of it is exhibit F. The plaintiff rejected the block as bogus and came to consult his solicitor to demand for him his original block. They however, forwarded that same bogus block which he again rejected. On 21 June [p.837] of [1980] GLR 833
1978 the defendants wrote the following (exhibit G) to the plaintiff:
“Dear Sir, SWOLLEN SHOOT BLOCK With reference to your letter dated 7 June 1978, I enclose herewith, the original specimen sent to us by your client, Mr. Rowland M. Bright from which the block was made.
Your client never sent us any block as alleged.
The reason for the delay in replying to your previous letters was that we had the impression that your client sent us a block and was all the time searching for that block.
It was however discovered after a thorough search that what we received from your client was the attached specimen and NOT a block as being alleged.
We hope this will clear the situation.
Yours faithfully, (Sgd.) J. K. Addo-Twum Editor—Graphic.”
To the plaintiff this was the last straw and so he brought this action.
The incumbent editorial manager of the defendants-corporation gave evidence for the defendants. According to him when in 1972 the defendants received an article on swollen shoot from the plaintiff, one Mr. Richard Horsley was the editor but he could not publish the article at the time. When he went on leave some time in 1977, one Mr. Addo-Twum took over and in May 1977 the plaintiff approached Mr. Addo-Twum and begged him to publish the article. The article was finally published as per exhibit E on 6 May 1977. Following the publication the plaintiff wrote to Mr. Addo-Twum to thank him and also to ask for the block to be returned to him—exhibit 1A. When they received this letter they all had the impression that the plaintiff had truly accompanied his article with a block on swollen shoot and so they conducted a fruitless search for the block. About a year later they conducted another thorough search through their files after they had received several letters from the plaintiff’s solicitor. Their search unearthed the original picture on swollen shoot (and not a block) which had been misfiled. It is the defendants’ case that that was what the plaintiff had originally sent to them accompanying his article. They wrote exhibit G forwarding the original specimen. They in turn received exhibit 2 from the
[p.838] of [1980] GLR 833 plaintiff’s solicitor calling their attention to a letter purported to have been written by Mr. I. K. Nkrumah on the subject. The defendants replied by exhibit 2A in which they insisted that the “original specimen” and not a block was what they received from the plaintiff and that Mr. I. K. Nkrumah and all of them were under a misapprehension that the plaintiff had sent a block and that was why they looked for a block.
Before the defendants had cause to amend their defence the issues as set out by the plaintiff had been admitted for trial and these are:
(a) whether the plaintiff has any cause of action;
(b) whether the plaintiff is entitled to his claims; and
(c) any other issue as may be apparent from the pleadings.
In paragraph (7) of the amended defence the defendants traversed that “the facts of the case do not give cause to any lawful action against them and that the suit herein is speculative and same must be dismissed.” In his evidence in court, the defendants’ editorial manager said that they published the plaintiff’s article gratis and that, just as in advertisements which are paid for by their clients, they make it clear to the clients that they are under no obligation for any loss of or damage to the material they bring. In what manner the defendants bring to the notice of their clients this absolution was, of course, not revealed to the court. Whether or not from his own evidence, the plaintiff has any cause of action will, in my view, be resolved by considering the general principles of law so well stated in Clerk & Lindsell on Torts (13th ed.), para. 1177 that:
“A detention is not wrongful unless the defendant’s possession is adverse. So it is not a wrong to omit to deliver the goods to the plaintiff where there is no contractual duty or duty as bailee so to do and where there is no intention to keep the goods in defiance of the plaintiff.”
In Capital Finance Co., Ltd. v. Bray [1964] 1 W.L.R. 323, the Court of Appeal approved the rule as accurately stated in Salmond on Torts (13th ed.) at p. 264 and held that no one is bound, save by contract, to take a chattel to the owner of it, his only obligation being not to prevent the owner from getting it when he comes for it. It is clear then that if there is no contractual obligation to deliver a chattel (or the defendant is under no duty to deliver as a bailee) an action will lie if, as explained in Clements v. Flight (1846) 16 M. & W. 42, there has been a withholding of the chattel and preventing the plaintiff from obtaining possession of it. As there is no contractual duty
[p.839] of [1980] GLR 833 imposed on the defendants and as the plaintiff has not made it part of his case that the defendants have wilfully withheld the block from him, the plaintiff cannot found his action on these matters and he must look elsewhere for his cause of action.
It is next to be considered whether there was imposed on the defendants any duty of a bailee, if they truly received the block. The law distinguishes three categories of bailees, viz. a bailee for reward, a gratuitous bailee and an involuntary bailee. In both cases of bailment for reward and gratuitous bailment it is the duty of the bailee to take all reasonable precautions for the safety of the goods bailed to him. If, therefore, such a bailee unlawfully or negligently loses or parts with possession he cannot get rid of his liability to restore the bailor’s property on the termination of the bailment. For the bailee to escape liability the burden will be on him to show that he took reasonable and proper care for the due security and proper delivery of that bailment: see Travers (Joseph) & Sons, Ltd. v. Cooper [1915] 1 K.B. 73, C.A. citing the House of Lords decision of Morison, Pollexfen & Blair v. Walton (unreported) dated 10 May of 1909. But the position is different in regard to an involuntary bailee, i.e. a person who through no act of his own comes into the possession of the property of another. Such an involuntary bailee has no such duty of care and he is impliedly authorised to take reasonable steps to return the property. But he cannot be tortiously liable where he merely keeps and loses a chattel even though the loss occurs through his negligence: see Howard v. Harris (1884) 1 Cab. & El. 253. The defendants, to whom the plaintiff allegedly forwarded his block without any prior contract or without the defendants themselves asking for it, stood in the position of an involuntary bailee and they cannot be sued in detinue for the loss of the block whilst in their custody. This explodes, in limine, the plaintiff’s claim for want of any cause of action.
An issue raised by the pleadings for determination is whether the plaintiff accompanied his article with a two-in-one block on swollen shoot or that he accompanied it rather with the specimen art-work or picture on swollen shoot. The plaintiff failed to produce his letter to the defendants (either in its original or his own copy of it) which forwarded the block. He, however, produced his letter of 1976 to the then Head of State (exhibit C) in which he complained, among other things, about the failure of the defendants to hand over his block to him. He also firmly rested his case on the defendants’ own assertion in exhibit D, that the two printing blocks on swollen shoot had been misplaced. I agree with the submission of counsel
[p.840] of [1980] GLR 833 for the defendants that exhibit D does not amount to an unequivocal confession as the letter says that the defendants had, in fact, nothing on file about his swollen shoot blocks. Their confession of loss was, it seems, based on their assumption that the plaintiff’s complaint to the then Head of State that he had forwarded the blocks was the truth. The defendants, on the other hand, also insisted that what the plaintiff actually sent to them was the specimen art-work on the swollen shoot which they discovered and forwarded to the plaintiff: see exhibits G and 2A. It should be noted that it was during the controversy over the alleged loss of the plaintiff’s block that they made their publication in exhibit E. The plaintiff has no quarrel with the pictures on swollen shoot which appear in exhibit E. The defendants could not have used a block (of the size of the picture in exhibit A) to produce those pictures. As the defendants properly explained they have a device to reduce the size of a picture to the desired block they have to use in their publication but they have no such device to reduce the size of a block to suit the required setting they desire of the publication. It follows then that the pictures in exhibit E which completely satisfy the plaintiff, could only have been produced by making a block out of a specimen art-work. The plaintiff says that the defendants made the block out of exhibit A which he claims to have forwarded to the defendants in compliance with their request in exhibit D for a copy of the art-work.
The defendants, on their part, say that they produced the picture in exhibit A from the specimen art-work which the plaintiff had forwarded to them together with his article. This art-work is what they claim to have forwarded to the plaintiff under their covering letter exhibit G. This covering letter did not mince words on the stand of the defendants. The plaintiff was asked to tell the court the whereabouts of the specimen art-work which the defendants forwarded to him in exhibit G and a complete blank was drawn. He, in fact, refused to answer that question. The plaintiff’s refusal to tell the court the whereabouts of this art-work forwarded by exhibit G has made the whole of his case, at best, bear macabre resemblance to Winston Churchill’s “riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma” of years ago. There was produced in court by the defendants exhibit 4, the block which they made for the plaintiff in replacement of the block allegedly misplaced by the defendants. Exhibit 4 is what the plaintiff describes as bogus and of which the print impression is exhibit F. It is quite clear that exhibit 4, from its size and quality could not have been used in exhibit E and it shows that the defendants made their own block to use in exhibit E. The plaintiff’s lack
[p.841] of [1980] GLR 833 of candour has left the court unable to resolve in his favour that he indeed forwarded a block to the defendants.
There was another aspect in which the plaintiff showed complete lack of candour and, even if he had a cause of action, I would have been disabled from assessing damages in his favour. The plaintiff’s much vaunted brain-work which he claims to have lost is, afterall, not the block he claims from the defendants. His brain-work is what he calls the masterpiece, i.e. the original art-work from which he made a copy in a reduced size to get the block made. This block, he told the court, was made by a printing house in Nigeria. With his exhibit A, all that is required is to get a printing house make one to his satisfaction and, if he had a cause of action, bill the defendants. Alternatively, he could call for the defendants to pay for his bill in getting the printing house in Nigeria produce the block. The plaintiff completely refused to tell the court how much he paid for his lost block. In General and Finance Facilities, Ltd. v. Cooks Cars (Romford), Ltd. [1963] 2 All E.R. 314, C.A. it was held that a successful plaintiff in an action in detinue who obtains judgment for the return of the detained chattel or recovery of its value is entitled to have assessed separately the value of the chattel at the date of the assessment. The court cannot, of course, properly carry out this duty of assessment, where the chattel has been lost, without the assistance of the plaintiff. This assistance is not forthcoming from the plaintiff. It is for all these reasons, and particularly for the reason that the plaintiff has no cause of action, that I dismiss the action, with ¢400 costs to the defendants.
DECISION
Judgment for the defendants.
D. F. L.
