SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1982] SLR (HC) 9High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL II)

DONKOR vs. NYARKO AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 963

2 April 1982 · OWUSU-ADDO J · ≈ 13 min read

Cite as[1982] SLR (HC) 9
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLADONKOR v NYARKO AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 963 [1982] SLR (HC) 9
APADONKOR v NYARKO AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 963, [1982] SLR (HC) 9 (Ghana).
BluebookDONKOR v NYARKO AND ANOTHER [1982-83] GLR 963, [1982] SLR (HC) 9 (Ghana High Ct. 1982).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASE REFERRED TO

Asamoah v. Ofori alias Renner [1961] G.L.R. 269.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

ACTION by the plaintiff to determine the proper person entitled to the grant of letters of administration in respect of the estate of a deceased intestate. The facts are sufficiently set out in the judgment.

COUNSEL

Mmieh for the plaintiff.

Asumadu-Sakyi for the first defendant.

Koduah for the second defendant.

JUDGMENT OF OWUSU-ADDOW J.

The proceedings in this case were commenced with an application ex parte filed by the plaintiff for grant of letters of administration in respect of the estate of Kwasi Amoakohene, deceased, who died in a motor accident on 28 July 1976. On 1 March 1977, a caveat was entered on behalf of the first defendant, describing himself as the general head of Asona family in Kumawu and a granduncle of the deceased. Two days later a second caveat was entered by the second defendant, who claimed to be the widow of the deceased. Both the first and second defendants opposed the grant of letters of administration to the plaintiff.

[p.965] of [1982-83] GLR 963

On 2 February 1979, Korsah, ordered the plaintiff to issue a writ of summons against the defendants herein for the purpose of determining the issue as to who is entitled to the grant of letters of administration. The plaintiff therefore issued a writ against the defendants claiming as follows: “The plaintiff claims that she is the customary successor to the deceased and the proper person to apply for letters of administration.”

In a statement of claim filed on her behalf the following averments were made:

“1. The plaintiff is the aunt of the deceased, Kwasi Amoakohene.

2. The plaintiff and the first defendant are all of the Asona family of Kumawu.

3. The Asona family of Kumawu has two heads, one in Kumawu headed by Opanin Kwaku Gyebi and the other at Pepease with Opanin Kofi Nyarko, the first defendant, as its head.

4. It is the custom of this family that successorship for a deceased person is appointed from the line from which the deceased belonged.

5. The plaintiff says that she succeeded to Madam Akosua Saa’s estate. Madam Akosua Saa is the mother of Amoakohene, the deceased.

7. The plaintiff says that when the late Kwasi Amoakohene died all the family members at Kumawu met and the first defendant was nominated as custom demands to appoint a successor but the first defendant refused to attend.

8. The plaintiff was therefore appointed by the head of Kumawu family, Opanin Kwadwo Adjei and other members.

9. The plaintiff says that the second defendant is not known as a wife to the deceased by any member of the family and has no interest in the estate of the deceased.”

The first defendant sought to controvert the facts alleged by the plaintiff and averred, inter alia.

“3. In further answer to the averment contained in paragraph 3 of the plaintiffs statement of claim, the first defendant says that, he is the abusuapanin of all the Asona family of Kumawu, Woraso, Senchie with the base at Pepease.

4. In further answer to the averment contained in paragraph 3 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim, the first defendant says that he has delegated Opanin Kwaku Gyebi Adu to watch over the Asona family of Kumawu for the first defendant who resides at Pepease, but Kwaku Gyebi Adu is not an abusuapanin properly so-called.

[p.966] of [1982-83] GLR 963

9. In further answer to the averment contained in paragraph 7 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim, the first defendant says that, he convened a meeting of the family at Pepease but Kwadwo Adjei and the plaintiff failed and refused to attend with the result that a successor has not been appointed by the first defendant to succeed the late Kwasi Amoakohene.

10. In further answer to paragraph 8 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim, the first defendant says that Kwadwo Adjei lacks the competence to appoint a successor.

11. In further answer to the averment contained in paragraph 8 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim which the first defendant says is particularly false, the first defendant says that in the history of the Asonas of Kumawu, a woman cannot succeed a male on the death of a male member of the family.

12. The first defendant as the abusuapanin of all the Asonas of Kumawu knows the second defendant to be the wife of the late Kwasi Amoakohene and they were married for about twelve years and the plaintiff knew the late Amoakohene was married to the second defendant.”

In her statement of defence, the second defendant denied that the plaintiff had been appointed customary successor to her deceased husband, Kwasi Amoakohene. Paragraphs 9-13 of her statement of defence stated:

“9. The second defendant denies paragraph 9 of the plaintiff’s statement of claim. The second defendant says in further answer to the said paragraph that as she is the senior wife of the deceased (to whom she had been married since 1 January 1964), the matrilineal family of the deceased took her (the second defendant) to the Nkawkaw Police Station on two occasions and she gave her statement to the police as such wife or widow of the deceased. The second defendant says that it was the very family members who came to take her (the second defendant) along to Nkawkaw saying that the police had demanded to see his (Kwasi Amoakohene’s), the deceased’s, wife or widow.

10. Again, when the deceased died, the second defendant was made by the family of the deceased to perform all relevant customary rites and during the funeral, she laid her own table as the lawful widow and received donations and the family thereafter took one sheep from the second defendant.

11. The deceased had performed all customary rites of marriage to the second defendant’s father, Yaw Krah and her head of family, Opanin Yaw Okyere at Effiduasi/Ashanti.

[p.967] of [1982-83] GLR 963

12. The second defendant therefore says that the plaintiff is not entitled to the reliefs she seeks as she (the plaintiff) is not the customary successor to her deceased husband.

13. The second defendant contends, and will contend at the trial that as the widow of the deceased and also a dependant of the deceased, she has a great interest or stake in whatever insurance compensation or benefit that may be paid to the dependants of the deceased and she must therefore be made a joint administratrix of the estate of her deceased husband.”

By their reply the plaintiff joined issues with the defendants and the issues and the additional issues formulated revolve around four main issues namely:

1. Whether or not the first defendant is the abusuapanin of all the Asona family of Kumawu, Woraso, Senchie and Pepease.

2. Whether or not the plaintiff was appointed as the successor of the estate of the deceased.

3. Whether or not Kwadwo Adjei is competent and capable of appointing a successor in the Asona family of Kumawu.

4. Whether or not the second defendant is the lawful widow of the deceased, Kwasi Amoakohene.

The plaintiff led evidence in her own behalf and called two other witnesses in support of her case. The gist of her evidence is that the deceased was her nephew. On the death of the deceased’s mother, the late Akosua Saa, she was appointed her customary successor; she is therefore entitled to succeed to the estate of the deceased. She said on the death of the deceased, Akosua Yankyere, the first plaintiff witness, was sent to inform the first defendant about his death but he refused to attend the funeral. On the fortieth-day funeral observation, the first defendant was again sent for but he refused to attend the funeral.

Due to a misunderstanding which arose between some members of the deceased’s family present on that day a customary successor could not be appointed. However, a week later, on a Friday, several members of the deceased’s family met and she was appointed the deceased’s customary successor by her uterine brother, Opanin Kwadwo Adjei, the head of their immediate family. She denied that in the history of the Asona family of Kumawu no female members had ever succeeded to the estate of a male member. She cited two instances whereby a female member of the Asona family of Kumawu had succeeded to the estate of a male member and vice versa. According to her, on the death of her uncle Kwabena Fegyare he was succeeded by his sister Akosua Donkor, and one Kwabena Adu of Pepease was succeeded by Amma Kona also of Pepease.

[p.968] of [1982-83] GLR 963

The first plaintiff witness, Kwasi Yankyere, is a grandnephew of the plaintiff. He said he was sent by Kwadwo Adjei first to inform the first defendant about Amoakohene’s death and the day fixed for the funeral observation but he refused to attend both the burial and the funeral. He confirmed the plaintiff’s story touching on her appointment as Amoakohene’s successor by Kwadwo Adjei and concurred in by several members of their family. Her second witness, Yaw Anokye, also confirmed that the plaintiff was appointed Amoakohene’s successor by her brother Kwadwo Adjei at a family gathering at Kumawu.

The first defendant said positively that he is the overall head of the Asona families of Kumawu, Woraso, Senchie and Pepease and Gyebi Adu, his first witness is his representative and head of the Asona family of Kumawu. He said it was this witness who informed him about Amoakohene’s death but he couldn’t attend the funeral because of ill-health. Giving his reasons for entering a caveat against the plaintiff’s application for letters of administration in respect of Amoakohene’s estate, he tendered exhibit 1 showing the family tree of the deceased.

This exhibit proved conclusively that with Amoakohene’s death, the family line of Ama Nyame to which line he belonged, had become extinct and the question of his successorship had to be decided by the first defendant, Gyebi Adu, his first witness, and the other elders of the family. On his part, the first defendant had not appointed the plaintiff to succeed Amoakohene and he had not clothed Kwadwo Adjei with authority to appoint Amoakohene’s successor. The plaintiff’s assertion of her appointment as Amoakohene’s successor and her subsequent application for letters of administration was therefore fraudulent.

The second defendant led evidence to show that she was the widow of Amoakohene and she had to perform the customary rites of widowhood on his death. Being a dependant and widow of the deceased, she has an interest in the deceased’s estate and is entitled to be made a joint administratrix of his estate.

In the granting of letters of administration the court is guided by certain principles and rules, the foremost of which is the interest of the estate and the will of those beneficially entitled to it. I have no doubt at all in my mind that usually it is the customary successor who is entrusted by the court with the administration of the estate of an intestate in this country: see Asamoah v. Ofori alias Renner [1961] G.L.R. 269. But sometimes the choice may fall elsewhere. The interest of the children in this case is to my mind, of paramount consideration. They are also included in the list of interested persons enumerated by Ollennu J. (as he then was) in the Asamoah case (supra). In any case, the Administration of Estates Act, 1961 (Act 63), makes

[p.969] of [1982-83] GLR 963 it abundantly clear that the choice of the court in granting letters in such a situation is not limited to the customary successor or other members of the family of the deceased: see section 79(1) of Act 63. The customary successor is however, the most eligible among the members of the family but section 79(2) of Act 63 says that he is to be considered alongside others. The subsection reads:

“(2) In granting administration the court shall have regard to the rights of all persons interested in the estate, including the successor, if any, under customary law, and, in particular, administration with the will annexed may be granted to a devisee or legatee and the administration may be limited in any way the court thinks fit.”

From my reading of the whole of section 79 of Act 63, I do not see any fetters imposed on the discretion of the court in granting letters of administration. That being the case, even if I find on the evidence that the plaintiff has been properly appointed Amoakohene’s customary successor it is not automatic that she should be granted letters of administration if I find that it would not be in the interest of the estate that she should administer it.

The evidence of the plaintiff and his witnesses show that the plaintiff’s appointment as Amoakohene’s successor was made by her uterine brother Kwadwo Agyei in the absence of the first defendant and his first witness, Opanin Gyebi Adu. It is not in dispute that the special circumstances of this case were such that in choosing Amoakohene’s successor, at least, Opanin Gyebi Adu should have presided at the meeting or gathering in the absence of the first defendant. From exhibit I the family line of Amoakohene became extinct with his death.

There was therefore no obvious successor and the question of such an appointment deserved the serious consideration of all the principal members of the family. But here, the meeting at which the plaintiff was allegedly appointed Amoakohene’s successor was not attended by either the first defendant or his first witness. Neither is there any evidence established that the plaintiff’s appointment as Amoakohene’s successor was authorised by them. I am fully satisfied that Opanin Kwadwo Adjei was not vested with authority to convene a family meeting to nominate and appoint the plaintiff as a successor to the late Amoakohene. Her appointment as Amoakohene’s successor is therefore incompetent and I find on the evidence the late Amoakohene’s customary successor is yet to be appointed.

But since the grant of administration on intestacy is not limited to the customary successor only, the question for determination is whether the plaintiff is the proper person to be granted letters of administration in respect of Amoakohene’s estate. The issue as to

[p.970] of [1982-83] GLR 963 whether a female member of the Asona family of Kumawu is eligible to succeed to a deceased male of the same family is neither here nor there. Admittedly, two rival views were given but I find myself unable to accept one in preference to the other in view of the paucity of evidence adduced on the issue.

However, being guided by the principle of interest of the beneficiaries under the estate, there is no gain-saying the fact that the plaintiff by her own showing, is not the proper person to whom the interest and welfare of the beneficiaries, especially the deceased’s children and widow could be entrusted. Throughout her case she denied that the second defendant was the deceased’s widow even though her own witnesses admitted this fact. No doubt her stand caused such an embarrassment to her counsel that he conceded that the second defendant is the widow of the deceased. Apart from this, the plaintiff proved to be a very untruthful witness. She denied that the first defendant is the overall head of the Asona families of Kumawu, Woraso, Senchie and Pepease even though her witnesses admitted that he is.

On the evidence, I am fully satisfied that the first defendant is the overall head of the Asona families of Woraso, Kumawu, Senchie and Pepease. Since Amoakohene died intestate his property became the family property of the Asona family of which the first defendant is the head. But for his advanced age, I would have found that the first defendant is eminently the proper person entitled to administer the deceased’s estate. Apart from the first defendant, the next qualified person is his first witness, Gyebi Adu, the head of the Asona family of Kumawu. I think he is the proper person to be granted letters of administration in place of the first defendant.

As regards the second defendant I find that she was lawfully married to the late Amoakohene according to native custom and was so married to him at the time of his death. She therefore has an interest in the property of the deceased.

The interest of the deceased’s infant children is in my view paramount. By virtue of section 77(1) of Act 63, I shall grant joint letters of administration to the second defendant and the defendant’s first witness, Gyebi Siaw Amu alias Gyebi Adu, to administer the estate of the late Kwasi Amoakohene of Kumawu. Accordingly, the deputy chief registrar is hereby ordered to issue a joint letters of administration to the aforementioned persons forthwith. Costs of ¢300 awarded against the plaintiff.

DECISION

Plaintiff’s action dismissed.

J. A. A.

Scroll to Top