SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1983] SLR (HC) 14High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1982-83 (VOL II)

PANYIN AND OTHERS vs. YAW [1982-83] GLR 1118

16 March 1983 · TWUMASI J · ≈ 6 min read

Cite as[1983] SLR (HC) 14
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAPANYIN AND OTHERS v YAW [1982-83] GLR 1118 [1983] SLR (HC) 14
APAPANYIN AND OTHERS v YAW [1982-83] GLR 1118, [1983] SLR (HC) 14 (Ghana).
BluebookPANYIN AND OTHERS v YAW [1982-83] GLR 1118, [1983] SLR (HC) 14 (Ghana High Ct. 1983).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPEAL against the decision of the District Court Grade II, Axim, wherein the defendants had been ordered to be ejected from a family house. The facts are sufficiently stated in the judgment.

COUNSEL

Dr. E. N. Tackie-Otoo for the appellants.

David Yaw Boateng for the respondent.

JUDGMENT OF TUMASI J.

This is an appeal from the judgment of the District Court Grade II, Axim. An action was instituted against the appellants herein by the respondent. For the purpose of this appeal, I would refer to the respondent as the plaintiff and the appellants as the defendants. The evidence adduced at the trial showed that the plaintiff and the defendants were members of the same family who traced their immediate ancestry to a woman called Amoo Yaaba who begat Amose Tanueh and J. E. Cudjoe. Assisted by her two children, Amoo Yaaba and a sister of hers by name Kwabla-ba jointly put up house No. 115,

[p.1120] of [1982-83] GLR 1118

Lower Axim. Amoo Yaaba, Kwabla-ba and J. E. Cudjoe had all died at the time this action was instituted leaving Amose Tanueh as the only survivor among those who put up the house.

As the law clearly states, where two or more members of a family acquire property by their joint efforts the property assumes the character of family property: see Sarbah, Fanti Customary Laws, p. 57. The plaintiff and the defendants are junior members of the Amoo Yaaba family, Amose Tanueh, head of the family had a room in the family house. Some time before the writ was issued, the third defendant without the knowledge of Amose Tanueh, forcibly broke into the latter’s room and took possession of it by fixing a new lock and key, and gave the room to his mother, the first defendant.

The remaining rooms are all occupied by the third defendant and his brothers and sisters to the exclusion of the head of family and other members of the family. The head of the family, Amose Tanueh, not being pleased with the state of affairs appointed the plaintiff to institute an action to eject the third defendant and those members of the family who had taken possession of the house to the exclusion of all other members. The trial magistrate, in giving judgment against the defendants stated:

“As members of the family they are entitled to a share from the one-third for the family and not the whole. In this instance the defendants have deprived any other member of the family including Amose Tanueh, the only living co-owner from entering the house. It is my considered view that Amose Tanueh has the power to eject the defendants and I enter judgment for the plaintiff.”

This decision has been attacked by counsel for the defendants as having been based upon wrong principles of law. Counsel submitted that members of a family cannot be ejected from a family house under any circumstances. Counsel for the plaintiff apparently conceded the point made by his learned friend but argued that the trial magistrate’s judgment could be varied by this court by making an order that at least one room should be given to the head of family, preferably the one of which he was wrongfully dispossessed. He based his appeal upon equity and fair-play. He severely condemned the conduct of the third defendant and submitted that it was unfair for the defendants to take exclusive possession of the family house.

This appeal raises the question of whether a member of a family can be ejected from a family house and if so under what circumstances. Sarbah in his Fanti Customary Laws describes the head of family as “Penin” while Danquah calls him “Abusuapanyin” or “patriarch” in his Akan Laws and Customs. Both share a common view that the head of family is the chief administrator and ruler of the

[p.1121] of [1982-83] GLR 1118

affairs of the family and his position commands respect and obedience from members of the family. He is endowed by customary law with powers necessary for the efficient administration of the family. Sarbah says at pages 37-38 of his book:

“The members of the family are bound to obey the lawful commands of the penin; he arranges the rooms in the family residence to be allotted to each, and what portions of the family lands each is to cultivate or possess. Rooms and lands so allotted continue in the possession of such persons and their successors until the penin re-arranges them.

When a member takes upon himself to take possession of the family property or a part thereof without the permission of the penin, he can be removed at any time, and another person placed in his stead.”

And Danquah states at page 205 of his book that an Akan patriarch:

“is more than a primus inter pares in that besides sharing the rights and duties connected with the trust property with all members of the family, he is entitled to exercise the power of a ruler over them and act as governor or final arbiter in their internal affairs.”

It seems clear to me that these two eminent jurists have stated correctly the customary law rules touching the position and powers of the head of family and I would place judicial stamp upon their pronouncements and hold that in wrongfully and forcibly breaking into a room which was being occupied by the head of family in the family house and taking possession of it and giving it to his mother without the permission of the head of family the third defendant wrongfully arrogated to himself the powers of the head of family by his rude conduct. Since the head of family was the substantive plaintiff in this case claiming for ejectment, the trial court was right in ordering ejectment. The proper thing to do in the circumstances should be obvious. I hereby order the immediate ejectment of the third defendant or his mother the first defendant, as the case may be, from the room which the third defendant forcibly took over and the head of family or his successor is hereby granted an order of possession of the said room.

The other members of the family can remain in the rooms presently occupied by them. I have also found as a fact from the evidence that the third defendant has given a room in the house to someone to sell akpeteshie (local gin) there without the permission of the head of family. I also order the immediate ejectment of the akpeteshie seller from the house and grant an order for possession to the head of family or his successor who would decide to re-allocate the said room to any

[p.1122] of [1982-83] GLR 1118

member of the family. The learned magistrate was partially right in his decision although he based his decision on wrong principles of customary law by holding that Amose Tanueh was a co-owner of the house and was thus entitled to eject the defendants. I order no costs in this appeal.

DECISION Appeal dismissed.

Decision of trial court varied. J. A. A.

Scroll to Top