SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1985] SLR (CA) 41Court of Appeal - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1984-86 (VOL II)

SEDORME vs. DODOR [1984-86] 2 GLR 79

15 July 1985 · APALOO CJ · ≈ 9 min read

Cite as[1985] SLR (CA) 41
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLASEDORME v DODOR [1984-86] 2 GLR 79 [1985] SLR (CA) 41
APASEDORME v DODOR [1984-86] 2 GLR 79, [1985] SLR (CA) 41 (Ghana).
BluebookSEDORME v DODOR [1984-86] 2 GLR 79, [1985] SLR (CA) 41 (Ghana Ct. App. 1985).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASE REFERRED TO

Balogun v. Balogun (1943) 9 W.A.C.A. 78.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

APPEAL from the decision of the High Court, Ho reversing the decision of the magistrate’s court in an action for declaration of title to and recovery of possession of a piece of land. The facts are fully set out in the judgment of Apaloo C.J.

COUNSEL

S. A. X. Tsegah for the appellants.

Akuaku for the respondents.

JUDGMENT OF APALOO C.J.

The facts of this case are in the main, not in dispute. A man called Gborbidzi founded a piece of farmland at a place called Dzita in the Anlo District. He seems to have farmed on it. He died intestate and this land devolved, according to customary law, on his children. He was survived by two male children by name Azametsi and Aforve. Upon Gborbidzi’s death, this land was partitioned, apparently, in equal shares, to his two children. The portion relevant to this case, is Aforve’s. The evidence suggests that Aforve entered into his portion and engaged in acts of husbandry on it until his demise. Like his father

[p.81] of [1984-86] 2 GLR 79

before him, he also died intestate. Aforve was married to two women. They were Dorvlo and Abuya. Dorvlo gave Aforve two children, a daughter Wormeshie and a son Bume. Abuya appeared to be the more fertile of the two. She begat three sons and two daughters. The sons were Doe, Dotse and Dodor.

The daughters were Dayome and Dadealor. Upon Aforve’s death, his portion of the land was partitioned among his four sons only, namely Bume, Doe, Dotse and Dodor. The daughters were excluded from the division. The evidence suggests that the partition to the sons was also in equal shares. The result of this division was that Dorvlo’s only son Bume received a quarter of the land. Her rival’s sons received three-quarters of the aliquot part of Aforve’s land. The parties in dispute in this suit are the lineal descendants of Wormeshie, Bume’s sister, and the other three male children, namely Doe, Dotse and Dodor.

It is common ground that Bume died without an issue. Had he been survived by a child or children, there would be no question that they would succeed to their father’s one-fourth portion of the entire Aforve land. Bume did not, in fact, die a known death. He was apparently a gong gong beater. He went on one occasion to perform this function and was never seen again. So he was presumed dead and funeral obsequies were performed for him on that basis.

The question that arose on Bume’s death intestate and without issue was, who was to succeed to his portion of the partitioned land? The person closest to him on the ground of consanguinity was his elder sister Wormeshie. The evidence is that she, with the full knowledge of Aforve’s other children, entered into the inheritance of her brother. She occupied and enjoyed this land. As she was the sole beneficiary of her brother’s estate, she was asked to provide funds to finance his funeral. She was not particularly well-off financially so she pledged a portion of the land to raise the money. According to the evidence, when Wormeshie was of advanced age and could not physically work on her portion of the land, she gave it to the first respondent to work on so they could share the proceeds in a proportion not precisely disclosed in the evidence.

The evidence further shows that the first respondent requested his maternal aunt Wormeshie to redeem the portion of the land she pledged to Abuya. Wormeshie was agreeable to this but as she had no funds of her own to do this, she asked the first respondent to redeem the pledge on her account. The first respondent did so with the sum of fourteen cedis (¢14). The upshot of this was that the first respondent became possessed of the whole of Wormeshie’s land, namely the part not in pledge and the part redeemed from the pledgee Abuya. On Wormeshie’s death, the appellants who were her lineal descendants requested the first respondent to relinquish possession of

[p.82] of [1984-86] 2 GLR 79

Wormeshie’s land which he had been cultivating to them. He readily surrendered the unpledged portion to them but retained possession of the portion he redeemed on Wormeshie’s behalf. At that time, there were growing crops on it. He promised to return this to the appellants after harvesting the crops. After harvesting the crops, the appellants repeated their request for the surrender of that plot. The first respondent then denied that he was in possession of their grandmother’s pledged land. In desperation, the appellants engaged in a form of self-help. Apparently, the latter were minded to enter upon their grandmother’s pledged land which they knew but they could not do so because the area was then flooded. When the floods subsided, they exercised their right of ownership by cultivating crops there. The respondents entered the farm and uprooted the crops and thus sowed the seed of this litigation.

The parties sought to resolve their difference before an elder called Dawukpor and some others. According to the appellants, the elders were satisfied that the area formerly pledged to Abuya properly belonged to them but in view of their relationship, they advised the appellants to relinquish their interest in one-half of the land to the first respondent in lieu of the refund of the money the latter paid in redeeming the land. Both parties were prepared to accept this compromise and a day was fixed for the division of the land into two halves. On that day, the first respondent changed his mind and refused to agree to the partition unless the unpledged portion was also split into two halves. On this account, the elders reversed their decision and directed instead that the appellants refund to the first respondent the pledged money to redeem the entire portion. They reckoned this at ¢80.15. The appellants paid this sum to the elders. The first respondent apparently at first received payment but again changed his mind and returned it to the appellants to provoke his action.

The respondents’ basic position was that on Bume’s presumed death, his portion of the land reverted to the Aforve family inasmuch as the appellants were female descendants and succession to an intestate was, according to Anlo customary law, patrilineal. They claim that Wormeshie was only permitted to enjoy the land for her life and upon her death, Bume’s land again became Aforve family land. When the first respondent was pressed to say who constituted the family in the context of this case, he said: “My father inherited the land after the death of Bume. Wormeshie was then alive.” The respondents are the descendants of Dodor. The magistrate found against them because in his opinion, after the partition of the land, the portion allotted to each son became his exclusive property. The respondents could only enjoy the portion left by their paternal grandfather Dodor but that Wormeshie

[p.83] of [1984-86] 2 GLR 79

was entitled to succeed to her brother Bume and on her death, and so that land devolved on her descendants. The appellants are the children of a female called Fuvi. The latter was the daughter of Wormeshie.

The magistrate accordingly, sustained the appellants’ claim of ownership and ordered that they recover from the respondents, possession of the farmlands in dispute but were to deposit into court the ¢80.15, which the respondents paid to redeem the land. The respondents for their part, counterclaimed for ownership of the land. The magistrate held that, that claim failed and dismissed it.

The respondents appealed against that judgment to the High Court, Ho. That court proceeded to reverse the judgment on grounds which are anything but substantial. The judge put to himself a number of irrelevant questions, but his main conclusion appears to be based on his holding that:

“ . . . the plaintiffs failed to prove that the portion of the land which was granted to Bume was granted absolutely to Wormeshie by the Aforve family. The statement that in these circumstances, the land of Bume become family land according to Anlo custom was not shown nor proved to be an incorrect and false statement of Anlo custom.”

For this reason, he held that “the magistrate was clearly wrong in law in entering judgment for the plaintiffs.” He then set it aside and proceeded to find for the respondents on their counterclaim. It is this holding that gave rise to this second appeal.

The main complaint made against the appellate judge’s decision is that he failed to take into account the position which resulted when the entire Aforve land was partitioned among his four sons. The magistrate’s view of it was that in view of the partition, each allottee became the exclusive owner of his portion. That statement of the customary law was right and made good sense. That indeed was the only object of the partition. The point is also covered by authority. In Balogun v. Balogun (1943) 9 W.A.C.A. 78, seven surviving children of a deceased partitioned the whole of their late father’s property among themselves. The West African Court of Appeal held that the partition of family land with the consent of all members of the family, conferred upon each member an absolute right to his partitioned portion. In this case, the only four sons who were entitled to inherit their late father’s land, partitioned it among themselves. Each accordingly became solely beneficially entitled to that portion and can, in all respects, treat it as his own.

Accordingly, on Bume’s death intestate and without issue, the person entitled to inherit this land is his sister of the full blood, namely [p.84] of [1984-86] 2 GLR 79

Wormeshie. The evidence of Azametsi was that: “Bume was born after a sister called Wormeshie Aforve. Wormeshie was made to inherit Bume’s property including the disputed land and to find money to meet the deceased brother’s funeral rites. “The magistrate obviously accepted this evidence and was clearly entitled to do so. The legal position was that the land lost the stamp of the Aforve family and became successively, Bume and thereafter Wormeshie’s land.

On Wormeshie’s death, that land devolved on her descendants. The appellants who are the children of Wormeshie’s daughter Fuvi, now stand in the shoes of Wormeshie and are entitled to succeed to that land as against Dodor’s descendants. That in sum, was the magistrate’s decision. That conclusion is in accord with customary law and justice.

The first respondent himself admitted in cross-examination that “the disputed farmland was the legacy left for Bume after the death of Aforve.” That being the case, the only question was, who was entitled to succeed to Bume on the latter’s death without issue? The learned magistrate appreciated this to be the issue. Yet the judge in error, held that Bume’s “legacy” lapsed back into the wider Aforve family property. That was clearly wrong. In my opinion, the magistrate’s conclusion was right both on the law and on the facts.

Mr Tsegah for the appellants, therefore invited us to reverse the judgment of the High Court and restore the decision of the magistrate. To that invitation, I very positively respond. Indeed, it wholly accords with my own view of the matter and the Anlo customary law as I know it. But for the conclusion to which the learned judge has come, I should have thought this a perfectly plain case.

I would allow the appeal and set aside the judgment of the High Court. In lieu of it, I would restore the decision of the magistrate with costs here and in the court below.

JUDGMENT OF MENSA BOISON J.A.

I concur.

JUDGMENT OF ABBAN J.A.

I also concur.

DECISION

Appeal allowed.

L.K.A.

Scroll to Top