SuperLawGHEngage · Educate · Empower
← All decisions
[1980] SLR (HC) 29High Court - GhanaGHANA LAW REPORTS 1981

KESSIE vs. NAMIH AND OTHERS [1981] GLR 444

25 April 1980 · ROGER KORSAH J · ≈ 12 min read

Cite as[1980] SLR (HC) 29
Other citation styles and permanent link
OSCOLAKESSIE v NAMIH AND OTHERS [1981] GLR 444 [1980] SLR (HC) 29
APAKESSIE v NAMIH AND OTHERS [1981] GLR 444, [1980] SLR (HC) 29 (Ghana).
BluebookKESSIE v NAMIH AND OTHERS [1981] GLR 444, [1980] SLR (HC) 29 (Ghana High Ct. 1980).

SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.

CASES REFERRED TO

(1) Bullock v. Lloyds Bank Ltd. [1955] Ch. 317; [1955] 2 W.L.R. 1; [1954] 3 All E.R. 726; 99 S.J. 28.

(2) Allcard v. Skinner (1887) 36 Ch.D. 145; 56 L.J. Ch. 1052; 57 L.T. 61; 36 W.R. 251; 3 T.L.R. 751, C.A.

(3) Baxter v. France (No. 2) [1895] 1.Q.B. 591; 64 L.J.Q.B. 337; 72 L.T. 183; 43 W.R. 341; 14 R. 263, C.A.

(4) Barclays Bank v. Tom [1923] 1 K.B. 221; 92 L.J.K.B. 346; 128 L.T. 558, C.A.

(5) Benecke v. Frost (1876) 1 Q.B.D. 419.

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS

ACTION by the plaintiff for the cancellation of a deed of assignment on the ground of fraud. The facts are sufficiently stated in the headnote.

COUNSEL

Cobina Kessie for himself as the plaintiff.

Hayfron-Benjamin for the co-defendant.

JUDGMENT OF ROGER KORSAH J.

[His lordship stated the facts (as summarised in the headnote) and continued.] The law, as I understand it, is that if M. D. Namih perpetrated a fraud on Cobina (with a C) Kessie, proceedings to avoid the transaction may be taken at any time while the influence still operated on the mind of Cobina (with a C) Kessie. But after the influence has ceased to persist, that is, after Cobina [p.447] of [1981] GLR 444

(with a C) Kessie in 1949 had demanded, obtained and read exhibits A and B in which appeared the recitals that he had assigned the whole of his interest to M. D. Namih, he was enjoined by the law to commence proceedings within a reasonable time: see Bullock v. Lloyds Bank Ltd. [1955] Ch. 317; otherwise he must be taken to abide by the transaction and confirm it: see Allcard v. Skinner (1887) 36 Ch.D. 145, C.A. In my view, 27 years is too long a time to wait before commencing proceedings to vitiate the transaction between him and Namih on the grounds of fraud, if there was ever any fraud.

Now in exhibit C, which is the original indenture of lease between the Government of Ashanti and Kobina (with a K) Kessie, the signatory for the Government of Ashanti was Major Francis Walter Fitton Jackson, C.M.G., D.S.C. and his signature was witnessed by J. R. Dickinson. Kobina (with a K) Kessie, who was described in the jurat as “being a person not being able to write,” also had his mark witnessed by J. R. Dickinson after the document had been interpreted to him by J. H. Folson.

Cobina Kessie admits knowing Jackson, Dickinson, who was Secretary to the Kumasi Public Health Board, and Folson. He also admits that his father and two brothers bore the same name of Kobina Kessie and that they were all illiterate. It also appears that apart from exhibit H, there is no other document dealing with plot No. O.T.B. 145 extant which has a Kobina Kessie therein described as literate, let alone as a teacher. And exhibit H was signed by Cobina (with a C) Kessie. I ask myself: Could Major Jackson—Acting Chief Commissioner of Ashanti, Mr. Dickinson—Secretary to the Kumasi Public Health Board and Mr. Folson, the interpreter, have conspired together to perpetrate a fraud on Cobina (with a C) Kessie? Is there any evidence that they did so conspire? Or is there any evidence of fraud on the part of anyone else?

The Records Officer of the Lands Department was called to testify on behalf of the co-defendant, and he made available to the parties the file in which all documents in the possession of the department, relevant to all transactions in relation to the property in dispute, reposed. That file was file No. K 98. The first document on record in file No. K 98 is a lease dated 13 May 1910 between the Government of Ashanti as lessor and Kwasi Amoako, as lessee (exhibit 1) for a period of seven years. On this lease, there is an endorsement in writing which reads, “Transfer to Kobina Kessie approved. Lease renewed for further period of—years from 1 April 1917.” This is the earliest record extant giving information of a dealing with the property in dispute since the British conquest of Ashanti.

[p.448] of [1981] GLR 444

Exhibit 1 contradicts the assertion by Cobina (with a C) Kessie that the plot was originally leased to a Senegalese gentleman who sold his hut on the property to him [Cobina (with a C) Kessie]. I find it impossible to accept that in 1910 there was a Senegalese gentleman by name Kwasi Adomako to whom the Government of Ashanti leased the property in dispute. If names are anything to go by, Kwasi Adomako was, more likely than not, an Ashanti.

Even if it is conceded that Kwasi Adomako was a Senegalese gentleman, the endorsement on exhibit 1 shows that the lease was subsequently transferred to one Kobina (with a K) Kessie in 1917. Cobina (with a C) Kessie testified that he was born in or around 1904; he commenced his education at the Government Boys’ School in 1910, and completed his education in that school in 1920. In 1917, Cobina (with a C) Kessie was still a schoolboy of some thirteen years of age. He was, therefore, not sui juris and could not have been entertained by the Government of Ashanti as a party to any contract affecting an interest in land.

It appears that on 25 March 1926 Kobina (with a K) Kessie required a “renewal of his house lease No.

419” and commissioned a letter-writer to write exhibit 2 to the Secretary of Kumasi Public Health Board requesting such renewal. Kobina (with a K) Kessie identified himself as the writer of exhibit 2 by making his mark. On his own showing, Cobina (with a C) Kessie was a literate school teacher in 1926; whereas Kobina (with a K) Kessie, the writer of exhibit 2, was, in 1926, incapable of writing a letter for himself or signing it after it had been written for him.

On 30 September 1927, a letter (exhibit 3) from the European Building Inspector gave Mr. Kobina (with a K) Kessie the terms under which a new lease would be granted to him by the Government of Ashanti. On 14 October 1927, Kobina (with a K) Kessie replied in exhibit 4 that be agrees “to rebuild on the same plot and take a new lease.” Exhibit 4 was also written for Kobina Kessie by a letter-writer and Kobina (with a K) Kessie identified himself as the writer by making his mark. The final offer for a new lease was given to Kobina (with a K) Kessie in a letter dated 6 December 1927 (exhibit 5). This new offer was accepted by Kobina (with a K) Kessie in a letter dated 9 December 1927 (exhibit 6) in which he agreed to the terms with his “whole heart.” Exhibit 6 was also written by a letter-writer and Kobina Kessie identified himself as the writer, once again, by making his mark.

On 15 November 1928, Kobina (with a K) Kessie, again employing the services of a letter-writer, despatched yet another letter to the Assistant Commissioner of Lands intimating that he had received

[p.449] of [1981] GLR 444

a lease No. 2263 for plot No. O.T.B. 145 for a term of 50 years as from 1 January 1928. These were the leases tendered by the plaintiff, i.e Cobina (with a C) Kessie as exhibits C and D.

On 11 April 1929, again through the services of a letter-writer, Kobina (with a K) Kessie wrote the following letter (exhibit 8) to the Assistant Commissioner of Lands, Kumasi:

“Sir, I have the honour most submissively to bring this to your kind information that I have actually given the plot 145 as per lease attached to one Moses Deeb Namih, a Syrian trader in town, therefore I humbly beg you to have my name cancelled from the lease and to prepare a new lease for the said Mr. M. D. Namih in lieu of same.

The said plot is not mine and is the property of M. D. Namih now. I respectfully trust that this will receive your kind attention.

I have the honour to be, Sir, Your humble servant His Kobina Kessie X Mark Right thumb of above.”

Thus on 15 April 1929, a deed of assignment (exhibit E) was executed between Kobina (with a K) Kessie as vendor, the Government of Ashanti acting by John Maxwell, Esq. C.M.G., Chief Commissioner of Ashanti and Moses D. Namih as purchaser. In this indenture too, Kobina (with a K) Kessie, consistent with the pose that he had taken as an illiterate since 1917, executed the deed by making his mark. The consideration for this assignment is stated both on exhibit 8 and in exhibit E as £390.

It is clear from the correspondence that the Kobina Kessie or Kessie to whom plot No. O.T.B. 145 was leased in 1917 was a person of full age who was unable to write. And on 15 April 1929, the said Kobina (with a K) Kessie was still an illiterate. The plaintiff, Cobina (with a C) Kessie, on his own showing, was a school-boy in 1917, and has been literate all his adult life. It is inconceivable that a lease of land would be granted by the Government of Ashanti to a mere schoolboy in 1917, and that in 1928 the then Secretary to the Kumasi Public Health Board would be a witness to the thumbprint of a teacher who is described as an illiterate.

[p.450] of [1981] GLR 444

Confronted with all these documents, the plaintiff proclaims that a fraud has been perpetrated on him by the defendants and certain officers employed in the Lands Registry. In paragraph 12 of his statement of claim he states :

“12. The plaintiff avers that the conduct of the defendants is fraudulent.

Particulars of Fraud:

(a) By substituting the original lease with another one which represented the plaintiff as illiterate.

(b) By substituting the original lease with another one which read that the plaintiff had assigned his whole interest including the reversionary.

(c) By altogether changing the whole original agreement and substituting it with a fraudulent one.”

No evidence was adduced by the plaintiff to substantiate these particulars of fraud. The plaintiff did not appear to appreciate that a repetition of the statements made in a statement of claim does not constitute proof of the veracity of such statements.

The most important documents tendered in evidence in this case were over 50 years old. And I believe the law to be that when documents are of such antiquity that witnesses who have corresponded with the supposed writer, or who have seen him write, cannot be produced, the law will, from necessity, be satisfied with less strict proof than is required in other cases. Such documents, when 30 years old, generally prove themselves; but still occasions may arise when, in order to establish identity, it will become necessary to prove the handwriting.

When the plaintiff was offered the opportunity of having the signatures of the Chief Commissioner of Ashanti and the Acting Chief Commissioner of Ashanti proved by comparison with their signatures on other documents, he spurned the offer and exhibited temper which is not in accord with a desire to establish the truth. There is thus available no evidence of fraud on the part of the defendants or any officer of the Lands Department. With exhibit H coming from the custody of the plaintiff and not the Lands Department, I am compelled to conclude that the plaintiff has never held the title to plot No. O.T.B. 145.

In or around 1974, the co-defendant heard that the house standing on plots Nos. O.T.B. 143 and 145 was up for sale. On 19 June 1974, he applied for an official search from the Lands Department in Kumasi (exhibit 9). On 26 June 1974, the Lands Department issued to him exhibit 11 which showed that there was an

[p.451] of [1981] GLR 444

assignment of his interest in the land by Kobina (with a K) Kessie to Moses D. Namih dated 15 April 1929. Relying on the abstract of title from the Lands Department, the co-defendant negotiated with the attorney of the first defendant, who was the third defendant, to purchase the house for the sum of ¢130,000. As the co-defendant did not know the third defendant, the cheque for payment (exhibit 16) was deposited with a Mr. Shadraway as referee. The deed of assignment (exhibit 10) was executed on 7 August 1974 and the third defendant took it away to collect her money. The co-defendant received exhibit 10 back towards the end of August, and he had it stamped and registered on 4 September 1974. He then left Ghana on an overseas tour on 6 September 1974 see exhibit 18.

The plaintiff complains that exhibit 10 was executed in the Lebanon, just because the receipt clause at the foot of the deed bears the stamp of the Embassy of the Republic of Ghana in the Lebanon, but this is explained by the fact that the third defendant took it away to collect the purchase price which from exhibit 18 was paid in cedis in Ghana by a cheque drawn on the co-defendant’s account with the Standard Bank Ghana Ltd. It was when the third defendant received payment that she executed the receipt clause. Since the cheque in payment of the consideration was drawn on a Ghanaian bank, unless the contrary is proved, the presumption must be that payment of the consideration was effected in Ghana. There is nothing to stop a party receiving the consideration in one place and executing a receipt clause in another. Fraud, wherever it is alleged, must be strictly proved. It cannot be inferred.

At the time of registration, all the writings and markings must have been on the document. And the assignment received the blessings of the Lands Commission. I cannot help but conclude that in the circumstances of this case, nothing irregular suggests itself to me.

In the pleadings, various amounts are stated which approximate to the real amount paid to one or other person. In one instance the pleadings state that £400 was paid to Kobina (with a K) Kessie when the evidence reveals that the amount paid was £390. In another, P. K. Sagoe was alleged to have paid as a consideration for the assignment to him, the amount of ¢137,000 whereas both exhibits 10 and 17 disclose that the consideration paid was ¢130,000. These errors in pleadings do not constitute evidence and they are no proof of the allegation that the defendants or co-defendant were parties to any fraud.

The evidence shows that, even if there had been fraud on the part of the defendants, which was not proved, the co-defendant

[p.452] of [1981] GLR 444

was a bona fide purchaser for value of the legal estate without notice of any fraud.

Finally, service of the plaintiff’s writ of summons and statement of claim was effected by substituted service. The defendants never entered appearance to the said documents, but the co-defendant whose attention was drawn to the writ sought and obtained permission to be joined as a co-defendant. Throughout the hearing of this case, the plaintiff contended that he was entitled to judgment against the defendants in default of their appearance to the writ. With the joinder of the co-defendant, it was no longer open to the plaintiff to take such a default judgment. The status of a co-defendant or a co-plaintiff is that of a person who is not a party to the suit but claims either to be a derivative owner or the grantor of one of the parties, and wishes to have the matter settled as between himself and any party in the suit. The position of a co-defendant or a co-plaintiff then is two-fold: Firstly, to prevent multiplicity of actions and to enable the court to settle disputes between all parties to them in one action: see Baxter v. France No. 2 [1895] 1 Q.B. 591, C.A. and Barclays Bank v. Tom [1923] 1 K.B. 221, C.A. and secondly, to prevent the same question from being tried twice with possibly different results: see Benecke v. Frost (1876) 1 Q.B.D. 419 at p. 422. Thus where a judgment against the defendants would not have precluded the co-defendant from asserting his rights in another action, such subsequent litigation could conclude differently from the previous judgments obtained against them. By waiting after the conclusion of the case I am enabled to enter a judgment which will be binding on all parties.

On the totality of the evidence, I am of the view that this action by the plaintiff was a bare-faced try-on. The plaintiff’s action fails and judgment is entered for and on behalf of the co-defendant. I award costs of ¢1,500 against the plaintiff.

DECISION

Plaintiff’s action dismissed with costs.

D. R. K. S.

Scroll to Top