ADA CO-OPERATIVE FOOD FARMERS UNION LTD. vs. ABODEI AND OTHERS [1982-83] GLR 1144
20 May 1982 · CECILIA KORANTENG-ADDOW J · ≈ 18 min read
[1982] SLR (HC) 2Other citation styles and permanent link
SLR is the Superlaw Reports citation series assigned by SuperLawGH. It is not an official law report. Suggested styles are a guide, so check your institution’s style guide.
CASE REFERRED TO
Henderson & Co. v. Williams [1895] 1 Q.B. 521; 64 L.J.Q.B. 308; 72 L.T. 98; 43 W.R. 274; 11 T.L.R. 148, C.A.
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS
ACTION for a declaration of title to certain tractors and equipment and the recovery of possession of same. The facts are sufficiently set out in the judgment.
COUNSEL
Dr. Ako Adjei for the plaintiffs.
Von Fleischer for the defendants.
JUDGMENT OF CECILIA KORANTENG-ADDOW J.
The plaintiff is an agricultural company incorporated and registered as a limited liability company. It’s claim is for a declaration of title to five tractors and their attachments. They are described in the writ of summons as follows:
“(i) Massey Ferguson 165 Tractor No. GL 3067;
(ii) Massey Ferguson 165 Tractor No. GL 3068;
(iii) Massey Ferguson 165 Tractor No. GL 3069;
(iv) Massey Ferguson 165 Tractor No. GM 1030; and (v) Massey Ferguson 135 Tractor No. GM-1029 together with five (5) ploughs, one (1) harrow, and four (4) trailers.”
[p.1146] of [1982-83] GLR 1144
It also claims recovery of possession of the said farm tractors and equipment; ¢330,000 damages for loss of use; ¢70,000 as general damages and mesne profits.
The plaintiff’s case simply stated is that the union bought all the tractors and equipment between 1969-70 with a loan from the Agricultural Development Bank, hereinafter referred to as the ADB, and so the tractors were all first registered in the names of the union and the bank.
In February 1976, the officers of the plaintiff union saw the defendants in possession of the tractors and equipment. The plaintiff’s officers made several attempts and great effort to retrieve them but they failed. They reported the defendants to the police and even to the military but the defendants asserted a claim of right on the basis that they had bought the tractors and the attachments. In their desperation, the union took this action.
The defendants are all citizens of Ada. They are brothers and they have been sued jointly and severally. The defendants’ case is epitomised in paragraphs 6 and 10 of the statement of defence. It is averred in paragraph 6 as follows:
“The defendants deny paragraphs 10 and 11 of the statement of claim and say thereto that the said tractors and the other machinery were completely broken down, and unserviceable and had been neglected and abandoned by the plaintiff union at various places in the country, and were being offered for sale by the officers of the plaintiff union who being insolvent and virtually bankrupt made the defendants to understand that they had decided at a general meeting to sell the machinery in that condition to enable the plaintiff union raise some money out of the sale to pay off an alleged debt to the Agricultural Development Bank and the defendants bought them in good faith and paid the selling price of ¢12,000 to the plaintiff union or their agents, servants and or officers.”hen in paragraph 10 it was pleaded:
“In answer to paragraphs 16 and 17 of the statement of claim the defendants will contend that the plaintiff union is bound by the deeds and acts and representations of its officers, to wit the president, vice-president, secretary, treasurer, servants and agents as aforesaid so far as they relate to the sale of the machinery to the defendants and are estopped from denying the sale to the defendants of the machinery in question, and alleging that the defendants merely took possession of or appropriated unto themselves and converted unto their own use and benefit, as alleged in
[p.1147] of [1982-83] GLR 1144 paragraph 10 of the statement of claim and other paragraphs thereof and therefore the plaintiff union is not entitled to its claim.”
But their evidence is that they bought all the tractors and equipment for that sum from one Azakpoe. Azakpoe was an officer of the Department of Co-operatives, which had guaranteed the loan from the ADB. He was the person who more or less liaised with the plaintiff union to see that the loan was repaid to the ADB. There is evidence which is not disputed to the effect that on one occasion when the plaintiff union defaulted in payment and the ADB made demands on the Department of Co-operatives, he was authorised by the then Commissioner for Social Welfare and Co-operatives and the Registrar of Co-operatives to go round the union members, with the aid of soldiers, to demand hiring charges from those members. The union hired out the tractors and equipment to members on credit basis. Some members owed the union for such hiring fees. The union gave Azakpoe a list of names of those who had defaulted in payment and Azakpoe went round the debtors collecting what they owed. On some occasions the officers of the union went with the debt collecting team. Azakpoe said that the collection of debts was between 1975-76. The sale of the tractors was effected in January 1976 – so the sale must have taken place soon after the collection of the debts.
But one thing is clear: By the evidence, the defendants had no dealing directly with the officers of the union, i.e. the president, vice-president and secretary as pleaded. A clear impression was given in the statement of defence that the union held out its officers as its agents to sell the tractors. It was on that basis that estoppel, was pleaded. Whereas by the statement of defence it was averred that the sale was contracted between the officers or the union or its agents, the evidence led by the defendants and their witnesses tried to show that the officers rather authorised an agent to sell for the union. On the basis of the alleged contract of sale, the defendants have counterclaimed for an order compelling the plaintiff union to complete the sale to them by having the items properly transferred into their names. They have also counterclaimed for damages for the inconvenience and harassment they suffered. When the officers of the union discovered that the defendant had taken possession of the tractors, they used all legal means to recover possession; they made a complaint to the police and the defendants were arrested but by showing the documents, exhibit 1 and 2, they were released. They were also reported to the Ghana Navy at Tema and two of the tractors were seized, but again they were released and the plaintiff was advised to come to court.
[p.1148] of [1982-83] GLR 1144
From the evidence it is crystal clear that prior to the alleged sale, the plaintiff union was the owner of the tractors and equipment. There is also no doubt that all these machines and equipment were allegedly sold to the defendants by one Azakpoe. As the defendants concede to the ownership of the tractors by the plaintiff union prior to the alleged sale, the legal burden is upon them to establish that there had been a sale of the machines to them. The defendants tendered two documents in support of their claim of purchase. The said Azakpoe who actually sold the vehicle also testified on their behalf. One of the documents tendered is a pro forma invoice issued by him for ¢6,000 being part-payment of the purchase price paid by the defendants. Both documents were prepared on the letter heads of the Department of Co-operatives and they purported to have been issued in Azakpoe’s official capacity as regional co-operative officer for Greater Accra Region. The issue therefore is whether Azakpoe could pass title in the machines to the defendants. His evidence was that Department of Co-operatives guaranteed the loan to the plaintiff union. When the loan was not repaid, the ADB made demands on the Department of Co-operatives for payment. The bank pestered them for payment so he took steps to recover the loan. As a first step, he was authorised by the commissioner and the Registrar of Co-operatives to employ the services of soldiers to demand hiring fees from the union members. The hiring fees did not settle the claim of the bank; so he said the bank asked its loan recovery officer to see to the disposal of the tractors. Subsequent to this he said he invited the president, vice-president and some members of the union to his office and he told them that the tractors should be disposed of as scrap. According to him the union executives and the members told him they would think about his proposal, so they left. Later, according to him, the president and vice-president returned and told him the machines should be disposed of. The president intimated to him that his brothers wanted to buy them and he brought the defendants to him, Azakpoe. Azakpoe negotiated with the defendants for the sale. He said he agreed to accept ¢12,000 for all the items listed in the alleged pro forma invoice.
All the items contained in the pro forma invoice are what the plaintiff claims in the writ of summons. By his evidence, therefore, Azakpoe purported to sell all the items to the defendants and issued his receipt for the part-payment made by the defendants. On the face of the document, neither the ADB nor the union was a party to the sale. The result being that even though the defendants eventually paid the full purchase price agreed between them and Azakpoe, the defendants did not get a transfer of the items sold. Under cross-examination, Azakpoe in his evidence conceded that he did not have the authority of the ADB to sell, even though in his examination-in-
[p.1149] of [1982-83] GLR 1144 chief, he said the bank had asked its loans recovery office to dispose of the tractors.
The legal position is that it is the ADB and the union as joint owners who can effectively pass title in the tractors and equipment as they would be the proper persons to sell. However, they may authorise any other person as their agent to sell on their behalf. Azakpoe would seem to be saying that he was asked to sell by the executives of the plaintiff union and that he did sell with the help of the loans recovery officer of the ADB. But there is no credible evidence in support of the alleged agency. In any case the loans recovery officer is not the ADB and in any such transaction it is not the help of one joint owner that is required. As stated above, it is the exercise of the right of sale of the joint owners that can pass title. Nothing more and nothing less. Therefore whether Azakpoe sold in his official or private capacity it is quite irrelevant to the sale. The Department of Co-operatives had no right of sale.
There was an intimation that the Department of Co-operatives guaranteed the loan so they had the right to sell. Such an assumption is erroneous. A guarantor has no right to seize the property he has guaranteed payment and sell. This is more so when the guarantor has not paid the debt. The defendants must have realised this that is why they sought to show that Azakpoe sold on the authority of the joint owners, namely the plaintiff union and the ADB. The evidence that he had the plaintiff’s authority to sell is not credible. I do not accept it. Both Azakpoe and the alleged vice-president, the first defendant witness described the circumstances under which the alleged authority was given by the plaintiff union and the bank. Yet, as I said, Azakpoe admitted later that he did not have the bank’s authority. The first defendant witness said the president of the union himself went with him and Azakpoe to the ADB and sought permission to sell the tractors and equipment and that the president told Azakpoe to sell them for ¢12,000. Azakpoe said he invited officers of the union to his office and they came with some union members and that he put the proposal of the sale to them. He said when they agreed to his proposal he fixed the purchase price himself. I do not believe that the president had any hand in the sale of the tractors. His indignation when he found out what had happened, and discovered the price for which all the five tractors and equipment were sold, and the fight he had put up to recover them convince me that he had no knowledge of the sale. There is also no evidence that the ADB authorised the sale. Azakpoe was not even certain whether they had been fully paid. He assumed that since it had not demanded payment from the Department of Co-operatives it must have been paid. There is no evidence of the exact balance outstanding due to ADB from the union. It would be very
[p.1150] of [1982-83] GLR 1144 strange indeed if the balance with the accruing interest was exactly ¢12,000 up to the last day the defendants made the final payment. If the society authorised Azakpoe to sell then Azakpoe was obliged to render accounts to it. Azakpoe’s conduct seems to be that of an official meddler. He had no right to sell and on the evidence, I do not believe or find that he was authorised to do so. It seems to me that he cashed in on the simplicity of the union officers. Looking at the ridiculously low price of ¢12,000 for which he sold the five tractors and all the equipment listed, I am convinced that he took advantage of the ignorance of the union officers.
The condition of some of the tractors was bad, but there is evidence that one was at G.C.M.T. under repair. That was eventually repaired. Soon after the alleged sale the defendants repaired two of the tractors and put them to use. These two were being used by the defendants at the time of seizure. That they could be repaired at all and put to use shows it is a fact that they were not all abandoned and unserviceable as was pleaded by the defendants and as completely useless as Azakpoe would seem to indicate. These tractors and their attachments were all bought new in 1969. In January 1976, they would not have been depreciated to as low as ¢12,000. The plaintiff could not have authorised sale and at that price.
With regard to the defence of estoppel by conduct counsel for the defendants did not make any mention of it in his address, but since that appeared to be the basis of the defendants’ defence, I would like to say one or two things about it. As was stated in Halsbury’s Laws of England (3rd ed.), Vol. 1, pp. 158-159, para. 374:
“Agency by estoppel arises where one person has so acted as to lead another to believe that he has authorised a third person to act on its behalf, and that other in such belief enters into transactions with the third person within the scope of such ostensible authority.”
It was again stated in Halsbury’s Laws of England (3rd ed.), Vol. 1, p. 208, para. 475 that:
“Where a person has by words or conduct held out another person, or enabled another person to hold himself out as having authority to act on his behalf, he is bound, as regards third parties, by the acts of such other person to the same extent as he would have been bound if such other person had in fact had the authority which he was held out as having . . .”
If it were established that the plaintiff union by its conduct enabled Azakpoe to hold himself out as the owner or as one entitled to sell, then the plaintiff union would be precluded from denying his authority to sell. As Lord Halsbury quoted the saying of an American judge,
[p.1151] of [1982-83] GLR 1144
Savage C.J. in Henderson & Co. v. Williams [1895] 1 Q.B. 521 at p. 529, C.A.:
“He is protected in doing so upon the principle just stated, that when one of two innocent persons must suffer from the fraud of a third, he shall suffer, who, by his indiscretion, has enabled such third person to commit the fraud.”
By the evidence, the plaintiff union did not hold out Azakpoe as its agent. Could it be said that by allowing them to collect debts from the defaulters who hired the tractors, the union had held him out by conduct as a person entitled to sell? The onus lies upon the person dealing with the agent to prove either real or ostensible authority. It is a matter of fact whether the agent had ostensible authority for the particular act. There was therefore no sale. The defendants acquired nothing. The plaintiff union has always remained the owner of all the five tractors and the farm equipment listed in the writ.
I would like to make one comment on the claim for declaration of title to the chattels in this case. In a claim for conversion or wrongful detention, it is not necessary to prove a title of absolute ownership. Therefore in an action of this kind, where the subject-matter is chattels, the appropriate remedy is a claim in detinue or recovery of possession and damages, if incurred. It is quite unnecessary to ask for a declaration of title in respect of chattel because actual possession or immediate right to possession entitles a plaintiff to bring an action for conversion. A fortiori, where the defendants have conceded that the plaintiff union is the owner of all the items and are merely saying that they had entered into a contract to purchase them, a claim for a declaration of title is quite unnecessary to indicate the plaintiff’s right.
I would make an order for recovery of possession in respect of all the five tractors and the attachments listed in the writ and statement of claim in favour of the plaintiff union. The first defendant said in his evidence that they collected all the machines. In the course of the proceedings an order for custody of the tractors was made and Mechanical Lloyd Ltd. was appointed as an interim custodian. I am informed by a copy of a letter addressed by the Mechanical Lloyd Ltd. to the counsel for the plaintiff that only two tractors and one trailer were recovered by them. I order that these be released by Mechanical Lloyd Ltd. to the plaintiff union on payment of the normal hiring charges agreed between them.
With regard to the damages for loss of use and trespass and conversion, the defendants say that all the tractors were not in good working order and that they had expended money to rehabilitate two of them. It would seem that these were the two which were recovered by Mechanical Lloyd Limited. I must say that it does not lie in the
[p.1152] of [1982-83] GLR 1144 mouth of the tortfeasor to say that the goods he had converted were in want of repairs or that the plaintiff would never have repaired them.
Conversion is an act of deliberate dealing with a chattel in a manner which is not consistent with another’s right to possession or right to possess it. The plaintiff has relied on conversion by sale, and wrongful detention and denial of right. The tractors were sold by Azakpoe, he committed conversion by sale. It is a pity he was not joined in the action. The defendants have wrongfully retained the tractors after they had been made aware of the true position and have dealt with the tractors in a manner that constitutes a denial of right to the plaintiff. The defendants have actively barred the plaintiff union access to the tractors. They have repudiated the plaintiff’s right to them. This is an act of conversion. The plaintiff has been deprived of the tractors, and in addition to recovery of the goods, the plaintiff is entitled to any special loss which is the natural and direct result of the wrong.
Generally, such a plaintiff is entitled prima facie to the value of goods plus any special damage. No damage or loss is established in respect of any of the tractors or their attachments. The plaintiff is entitled only to any special loss it has suffered. The special loss it claims is loss of use. The evidence is that each tractor and all its attachments were hired out at ¢100 per diem. It therefore claims ¢500 per diem for the five tractors for five working days a week. From all indications not all the five tractors were in good working order at the time of the illegal sale. In fact the plaintiff gave evidence generally that that was the hiring charge but it is not certain whether they were in a condition to be rented out at the time. It is not for a tortfeasor to say that the plaintiff is not entitled to damages because the chattel was not in good condition, and would have remained in such condition at all times.
The plaintiff might have put all of them in good working order but the defendants by their tortious act deprived them of that right. Nevertheless, judging from the evidence I cannot say with any confidence that the plaintiff would have earned all what they claim considering also that there might have been days when they would have remained unhired and the fact that only two of the tractors are in good working condition, I think this is a case where the plaintiff should be entitled to nominal damages. I think ¢50,000 would be adequate in the circumstances. I enter judgment for the plaintiff for that sum against the defendants jointly and severally.
There is a claim for mesne profits. Mesne profits is a concept of land litigation and appurtenance of actions for trespass. There is no room for the application of that principle in this case. Perhaps the relief the plaintiff sought in that form is damages for loss of use from the time of the action to the date of judgment. In my judgment, since the defendants persisted in their claim to the tractors thus denying the
[p.1153] of [1982-83] GLR 1144 plaintiff’s right to them, the tort of conversion committed by the defendants continued up to date and special damage suffered up to date may be claimed by the plaintiff. That is the general position.
Since the evidence established that only two of the tractors were in good working condition I would have allowed loss of use in respect of those two, because as I said the defendant’s claim of right has continued up to date. However, looking at the way the plaintiff operated the tractors and their inability even to collect hiring fees I cannot say that it would have earned such regular income. As I held it is entitled to nominal damages. I make no order under that leg.
The defendants’ counterclaim fails on both legs for obvious reasons. A person cannot claim to have suffered loss of reputation where there is no such reputation to protect. The defendant had unlawfully taken possession of the plaintiff’s tractors and equipment and all the steps which the plaintiff took to recover possession only amounted to making legitimate demands and exercising a claim of right. They cannot give a cause of action to the tortfeasor whose conduct had occasioned such exercise of a claim of right. The claim for a transfer of the property in the tractors also fails because those who had title to convey did not authorise the sale. There is therefore no basis for the claim. The counterclaim is therefore dismissed. I would grant ¢2,000 costs for the plaintiff against the defendants.
DECISION
Judgment for the plaintiff.
Counterclaim refused. M. C. N. N.
